Mediagazer: The Problem with “The Newsroom's” Critics - They're Journalists (Robert Schoon/On The Media)

8:00 AM ET, June 29, 2012

Top News:

Rem Rieder / American Journalism Review:

Who Was First? Who Cares? — The ridiculous battle over who “broke” the news on the health care ruling―and why it's dangerous. Thurs., June 28, 2012. — Rem Rieder (rrieder@ajr.umd.edu) is AJR's editor and senior vice president. — Q: Which news organization was first to report …

Discussion: Gawker, Poynter, Tampa Bay Times, Online NewsHour and New York Magazine

Michael Hastings / BuzzFeed:

CNN News Staffers Revolt Over Blown Coverage — News staffers at the cable network CNN, long the gold standard in television news, were on the verge of open revolt Tuesday after CNN blew the coverage on the most consequential news event of the year. As Chief Justice John Roberts began reading …

Discussion: The Daily Beast, Business Insider, Politico, Gawker, @producermatthew, The Huffington Post, BostInno, The Daily Caller and Collective Talent

Andrew Beaujon / Poynter:

CNN issues correction, Fox issues statement on Supreme Court reporting mistakes — The ruling has come down: Both CNN and Fox badly bungled their reporting of today's landmark Supreme Court opinion on healthcare. And both organizations have taken very different routes to correcting their mistakes.

Discussion: NetNewsCheck Latest, The Daily Beast, New York Times, Forbes, CNN and The New Yorker Blog

Felix Salmon:

News Corp's digital divergence — There's no secret why Rupert Murdoch is breaking News Corp into two pieces. Amy Chozick explains: … It's worth underscoring the fact, here, that Fox News, Sky News, and Fox Business are going to end up on the entertainment, rather than the news …

Discussion: NPR and Reuters

Jeff Sonderman / Poynter:

CNN, Fox News err in covering today's Supreme Court health care ruling — The Supreme Court announced its ruling on the Affordable Care Act around 10:15 a.m. EST. CNN mistakenly reported that the individual mandate was struck down. Screenshots show the mistake and the subsequent change.

Jim Romenesko:

Bloomberg News: We were first with health care ruling — A Bloomberg News PR person writes: Just wanted to reach out about your post about the coverage of today's Supreme Court health care ruling. You reference an email that notes that the AP first reported the decision — by our records …

Discussion: Erik Wemple and SCOTUSblog

Jake Tapper / ABCNEWS:

POTUS First Learned Erroneous News on Court Decision from Cable TV — President Obama was just outside the Oval Office Thursday morning when he got the news — erroneous, as it turned out — that the U.S. Supreme Court had struck down the individual mandate in his signature health care law, deeming it unconstitutional.

Discussion: Poynter, New York Magazine, Adweek, The Huffington Post, Mashable!, Mediaite, Gawker, TVNewser, CNN, Guardian and Washington Wire

Jim Romenesko:
AP orders staff to stop taunting news outlets for getting health care ruling wrong

Discussion: NPR, Gawker, Vanity Fair, Mediaite, New York Magazine and Politico

Erik Wemple:
CNN correction on health-care ruling: Insane

Discussion: Mediaite and Forbes

Jim Romenesko:
‘CNN fails badly on health care decision’

Discussion: Jack Shafer, Forbes, Media Nation and Mediaite

Sarah Kliff / Washington Post:
For SCOTUSblog, one goal: ‘Beat everybody’ and break news of health-care ruling

Discussion: FishbowlDC, Mediaite, Poynter, New York Times, Online NewsHour, Mashable! and @onthemedia

Ingrid Lunden / TechCrunch:

Murdoch Says Separated News Corp Publishing Biz Will ‘Push Even Harder’ On Charging For Content — Old media, some think, is headed for the graveyard, and they'll be damned if it takes young and cool new media with it. But it ain't dead yet, and some growling comments made today by Rupert Murdoch …

Discussion: Guardian, NetNewsCheck Latest, The Next Web and Poynter

Michael Calderone / The Huffington Post:
Rupert Murdoch Suggests Wall Street Journal Won't Face Cuts In News Corp. Split

Discussion: Business Insider and WebProNews

Staci D. Kramer / paidContent:
The Murdoch media tour: Spinning the spinoff

Discussion: NetNewsCheck Latest, Capital New York and Radio & Television …

Yinka Adegoke / Reuters: News Corp split sets stage for possible Lachlan return

Mark Sweney / Guardian:
Tom Mockridge and Robert Thomson tipped to head News Corp's press arm

Discussion: NPR and Media Week

Bloomberg:

Microsoft Said To Plan Xbox Music Rivaling Apple, Spotify — Attendees at the E3 Expo in Los Angeles, June 5, 2012. Microsoft Corp. expanded the sports and entertainment content offered through the Xbox, and is planning to add iTunes and Spotify for music.

Discussion: PC Magazine, MacRumors, The Wrap and Engadget

Alexandra Alter / Wall Street Journal:

Your E-Book Is Reading You — Digital-book publishers and retailers now know more about their readers than ever before. How that's changing the experience of reading. — It takes the average reader just seven hours to read the final book in Suzanne Collins's “Hunger Games” trilogy on the Kobo e-reader—about 57 pages an hour.

Discussion: Digital Book World and The Verge

Adrienne LaFrance / Nieman Journalism Lab:

NewsGame aims to populate a virtual world with real reporting and pretend correspondents — Game makers turned to journalism for inspiration long before Atari gave us Paperboy. There was Deadline in the 1970s, and Scoop and Calling Superman in the 1950s. (If you want to get really old-school, see Round the World with Nellie Bly.)

Robert Schoon / On The Media:

The Problem with “The Newsroom's” Critics - They're Journalists — Reviews of Aaron Sorkin's new HBO show The Newsroom have so far been mixed. But are journalists the fairest judges for this TV show? — Since before The Newsroom aired on HBO last Sunday night, nearly every critic …

Discussion: The Huffington Post, American Journalism Review and The New Yorker Blog

Sharon Waxman / The Wrap:

Ann Curry Mess: Did NBC Learn Nothing From Conan O'Brien? — Ann Curry's messy exit suggests that despite NBC's new regime the new crew has learned nothing from the old crew and the ghost of Conan O'Brien. — Once again, a prominent piece of talent - this time Curry - was left hanging out to dry …

Merrill Knox / TVNewser:
Ann Curry Says Emotional Goodbye to ‘Today’: ‘This Is Not as I Expected to Ever Leave This Couch’

Discussion: TVSpy, The Daily, Radio & Television …, @huffpostmedia, AdAge and Broadcasting & Cable

Lisa O'Carroll / Guardian:

Operation Elveden: Police arrest man on suspicion of corruption — A former NHS employee has been arrested by Scotland Yard officers investigating allegations of inappropriate payments by newspapers to police and public officials. The 31-year-old man was arrested about 6am on Thursday …

Discussion: Press Gazette