Top News:
Alex Barker / Financial Times:
Without naming Fox, James Murdoch blasts media owners who enabled “toxic politics” and says their lies have unleashed “insidious and uncontrollable” forces — Comments from Rupert's son are his strongest rebuke of industry practices since leaving the family business
Discussion:
@oliverdarcy, CNN, @kathrynamurdoch, Variety, @wajahatali, contextisking.com, @kathrynamurdoch, @katebevan, @stewartmcdonald, @raydalio, @mmasnick, @swannyqld, @samthielman, @originalspin, @billkristol, @turnbullmalcolm, @richardajkeys, @clairecmc, @mrkrudd, @liseinthecity, @mattgarrahan, @joyannreid, @ashkan, @bostonjoan, @tucker5law, @stopfundinghate, @poniewozik, @robinwigg, @fascinatorfun, @andrewcooper__, @maynereport, @lisatozzi, @timbrooks100, Business Insider, @janinegibson, @alexebarker, @suanzes, @oliverdarcy and The Hill
Discussion:
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: Full statement from James Murdoch & @KathrynAMurdoch: “Many media property owners have as much responsibility for this as the elected officials who know the truth but choose instead to propagate lies...” https://www.cnn.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Oliver Darcy / CNN: James Murdoch criticizes ‘media property owners’ who have ‘unleashed insidious’ forces with election denialism claims
Kathryn Murdoch / @kathrynamurdoch: Our statement: Spreading disinformation — whether about the election, public health, or climate change — has real world consequences. Many media property owners have as much responsibility for this as the elected officials who know the truth but choose instead to propagate lies
Ellise Shafer / Variety: James Murdoch Denounces ‘Media Property Owners’ for ‘Spreading Disinformation’ Leading to Capitol Riot
@wajahatali: If you don't believe me, listen to Rupert Murdoch's son. He knows what's up. Rupert and Lachlan are some of the biggest threats to democracy in the 21st century. https://twitter.com/...
Ashkan Karbasfrooshan / contextisking.com: Born on Third Base
Kathryn Murdoch / @kathrynamurdoch: We hope the awful scenes we have all been seeing will finally convince those enablers to repudiate the toxic politics they have promoted once and forever.
Stewart McDonald MP / @stewartmcdonald: I'd like to hear an honest reflection of his own role in this over the years and maybe, y'know, an apology for it. https://www.ft.com/...
Ray Dalio / @raydalio: They appear to be right in observing that there is a backlash brewing against distortions in the media. I hope so and hope that will lead to greater accuracy of reporting. https://www.ft.com/... (5/5)
Mike Masnick / @mmasnick: Dude. James ran News International, and then took over Fox and was deeply connected to Fox News for years. I know he resigned by saying he disagreed with editorial decisions, but this is pointing fingers at others for the monster he helped build. https://twitter.com/...
Wayne Swan / @swannyqld: “The damage is profound the sacking of the Capitol is proof positive that what we thought was dangerous is indeed very..Those outlets that propagate lies to their audience have unleashed insidious and uncontrollable forces that will be with us for years.” https://www.ft.com/...
@samthielman: live footage of the murdochs trying to find the guys who did this https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Bill Kristol / @billkristol: “Spreading disinformation...has real world consequences. Many media property owners have as much responsibility for this as the elected officials who know the truth but choose instead to propagate lies.” https://www.cnn.com/...
Malcolm Turnbull / @turnbullmalcolm: “Spreading disinformation — whether about the election, public health or climate change — has real world consequences,” James and Kathryn Murdoch said in a joint statement following the @FT interview. 1/2
Richard Keys / @richardajkeys: This is remarkable - from the man who led the Murdoch media during the greatest journalistic scandal of any era - phone hacking. These people know no shame. https://amp.ft.com/...
Claire McCaskill / @clairecmc: This doesn't help. Firing Dobbs and Bartiromo and Pirro and Levin would be a good start. https://twitter.com/...
Kevin Rudd / @mrkrudd: A massive blast from James Murdoch pinning responsibility for US violence on far-right media led by Murdoch's FoxNews. James spent decades inside the Murdoch machine, and knows it better than anyone. The case for #MurdochRoyalCommission is undeniable. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Lise Hand / @liseinthecity: Irony is dead as a parrot, it's run down the curtain and joined the choir invisible https://twitter.com/...
Matthew Garrahan / @mattgarrahan: If only James Murdoch, as chief executive of the company that owns Fox News from 2015-2019, had been in a position to do something about how media networks cover the news https://twitter.com/...
@joyannreid: Rupert Murdoch's youngest son, James Murdoch and his wife unload on the media villains that include his own father and brothers. Wow. https://twitter.com/...
Ashkan Karbasfrooshan / @ashkan: The media needs to ignore the Murdochs or give them the Trump treatment: https://www.mediagazer.com/... A case better late than never, or lacking awareness and being a hypocrite? https://contextisking.com/...
Joan Donovan, PhD / @bostonjoan: If she really wants to do something about disinformation, she should fund independent research on partisan media effects. https://twitter.com/...
Malcolm Tucker Esq / @tucker5law: This self awareness lark is harder than you think. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@stopfundinghate: James & Kathryn Murdoch: “Many media property owners have as much responsibility for this... We hope the awful scenes we have all been seeing will finally convince those enablers to repudiate the toxic politics they have promoted once and forever” 🌶️🌶️ 🌶️ https://www.ft.com/...
James Poniewozik / @poniewozik: This is the exact midpoint between the Kendall Roy Denounces Logan gif and the We're All Trying to Find the Guy Who Did This gif https://twitter.com/...
Robin Wigglesworth / @robinwigg: If only he knew someone who could do something about it. https://twitter.com/...
Fionna O'Leary / @fascinatorfun: Let's face it. His family have done enough damage 8n the U.K. But what is he going to do to turn that around? https://twitter.com/...
Stephen Mayne / @maynereport: Well done, although it shouldn't have taken James Murdoch 10 weeks to speak out since it became apparent Trump had lost the election and some of the Fox News partisans were backing the President's fanciful lies about the election being stolen https://www.ft.com/...
Tim Brooks / @timbrooks100: @janinegibson The fact that his Damascene conversion followed, rather than preceded, his becoming a billionaire due to the sale of most of Fox, is surely coincidental?
Sophia Ankel / Business Insider: James Murdoch, son of Fox News mogul Rupert Murdoch, said news outlets that promoted ‘lies’ are to blame for US Capitol riot
Janine Gibson / @janinegibson: James Murdoch's journey from presider over News UK during phone hacking to denouncer of Big Media continues to be biblical in scale https://twitter.com/...
Alex Barker / @alexebarker: I asked James Murdoch about Fox News and the assault on the Capitol. He has...strong views https://www.ft.com/...
Pablo R. Suanzes / @suanzes: “Many media property owners have as much responsibility for this as the elected officials who know the truth but choose instead to propagate lies. We hope the awful scenes we've been seeing will finally convince those enablers to repudiate the toxic politics they have promoted”. https://twitter.com/...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: Without mentioning Fox News directly, James Murdoch tells @FT, “Outlets that propagate lies to their audience have unleashed insidious and uncontrollable forces that will be with us for years...” https://www.ft.com/...
Celine Castronuovo / The Hill: James Murdoch predicts ‘a reckoning’ for media after Capitol riot
RELATED:
The Daily Beast:
Sources: Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch are “disenchanted” with Fox News CEO Suzanne Scott and President Jay Wallace; total viewership is down 15% YoY since Dec. 28
Sources: Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch are “disenchanted” with Fox News CEO Suzanne Scott and President Jay Wallace; total viewership is down 15% YoY since Dec. 28
Discussion:
Jay Rosen / @jayrosen_nyu: “This month to date, CNN has averaged 2.08 million viewers throughout the day; MSNBC has averaged 1.74 million; and Fox has averaged 1.41 million. Even in prime time, when Fox is at its strongest, it has been stuck in third place.” https://view.newsletters.cnn.com/ ...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: There is nothing Fox and its fans like to do more than point to its ratings and mock others for theirs. But, stuck in third place, it suddenly can't point to the ratings scoreboard. Read @brianstelter on the TV news realignment: https://view.newsletters.cnn.com/ ...
Brian Stelter / @brianstelter: Here's the weekend edition of our @ReliableSources letter: https://view.newsletters.cnn.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Bruno J. Navarro / @bruno_j_navarro: Fox News CEO Suzanne Scott's Job Is in Jeopardy, Insiders Say ... To make matters worse, Fox has also suffered historic ratings losses to CNN and MSNBC, despite an intensely dramatic news cycle. https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Brian Stelter / @brianstelter: The TV news realignment: Ratings for Fox News have sagged ever since Election Day. And CNN's ratings have surged to historic levels https://view.newsletters.cnn.com/ ...
Kim Sherrell / @kim: @benyt 🔥 🗑 Quote from #FoxNews CEO @Suzannescott is really something. She doesn't care. Has “enough money to never work again.”
Justin Baragona / @justinbaragona: NEW from @LachCartwright, @dianafalzone, @TheLloydGrove and me. Amid Fox's sagging ratings, Rupert Murdoch has taken a more hands-on approach at the network — and Suzanne Scott's days as Fox CEO appear to be numbered as she takes the brunt of the blame. https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Jane Mayer / @janemayernyer: Fox ratings are cratering - “after getting viewers hooked on heroin of outrage” story says viewers are leaving for even more toxic coverage. https://twitter.com/...
Patrick McGee / @patrickmcgee_: Imagine being a reporter at a company described like this: A significant portion of the network's conservative viewership has abandoned Fox for Newsmax, a rival pro-Trump channel that openly disregards factual reporting https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
@ericbolling: “things that are Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch's fault”... what do you know Ben? https://twitter.com/...
Colby Hall / Mediaite: Fox News is on a Historic Run at Last Place in Cable News. Here Are the Reasons Why.
Noah Shachtman / @noahshachtman: “When pressed for a statement of support for Scott from Fox CEO Lachlan Murdoch none was forthcoming.” https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Joe Pompeo / Vanity Fair:
Politico announces new members of its Playbook team, expanding from two writers to four: Rachael Bade, Eugene Daniels, Ryan Lizza, and Tara Palmeri — Facing stiffer competition, a new crew of writers—Ben Shapiro not included—is promising more scoops and scene as the O.G. political tip sheet reboots …
Discussion:
@oliverdarcy, @politicopress, @tarapalmeri, @aloisedphelps, @eugenedaniels2, @meghanmccain, @mattyglesias, @therealhoarse, @carloslozadawp, @back_ttys, @fenitn, @r_allbritton, @ahmed, @nancook, @rush_hour1, @eoinhiggins_, @lachlan, @jonallendc, @ryanlizza, @justinbaragona, @froomkin, @tarapalmeri, @rachaelmbade, @seungminkim, @jakesherman, @tarapalmeri, @joshchafetz, @meredithshiner, @tarapalmeri, The Wrap, Washingtonian, @abrowngaywrites, Media Matters for America and The Federalist
Discussion:
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: Politico's leadership officially announces new Playbook team in internal memo: @rachaelmbade, @EugeneDaniels2, @RyanLizza, and @tarapalmeri. They start January 19th. https://twitter.com/...
Politico Press / @politicopress: 🚨 We are thrilled to announce that @rachaelmbade, @EugeneDaniels2, @RyanLizza & @tarapalmeri will take the reins of POLITICO Playbook starting Jan. 19! 🚨 Check out their exclusive interview with @VanityFair's @joepompeo below. https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Tara Palmeri / @tarapalmeri: .@joepompeo nailed it: “You can expect more dish, more gossip, more scene, a bit more of a certain rakish tabloid sensibility that will help snap you awake at 6 a.m. A little less khaki, a little more denim..more of a willingness to push some buttons."https://www.vanityfair.com/ ...
Aloise / @aloisedphelps: i've been waiting all day to put in my 2 cents on this news. you'd be hard pressed to find a better journalist, let alone person, than @EugeneDaniels2 . grateful for his sharp intellect, quick wit, and fierce friendship every damn day. go get em, gene! https://twitter.com/...
Eugene Daniels / @eugenedaniels2: Personal news: Who would've thought that nosy, loud, gay, Black boy would one day get to cover the White House, (VP Harris, Emhoff and Dr. Biden) & author Playbook! So excited for to be teaming up with @RyanLizza @rachaelmbade & @tarapalmeri! Send me ALL your political tea! https://twitter.com/...
Meghan McCain / @meghanmccain: This made my afternoon! Congratulations @tarapalmeri!!! 👏🏻👏🏻 👏🏻👏🏻 👏🏻👏🏻 👏🏻🇺🇸 🇺🇸🇺🇸 🇺🇸🇺🇸 🇺🇸 https://twitter.com/...
@therealhoarse: “I wanted to see, what if we created a kind of small team of elite journalists, people who can [...] own the Hill but also rove the salons of Georgetown, or wherever the elite will be gathering,” Self-importance level: elite https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Carlos Lozada / @carloslozadawp: “There's gotta be one new scoop in there every day, one conceptual or intellectual scoop every day; it's gotta have the big headlines; there's gotta be aggregation. . . and finally, some sort of dessert at the end.” Meet the new POLITICO PLAYBOOK: https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Lord BT / @back_ttys: This sounds like the most insufferable thing on earth, and the photograph doesn't help. https://www.vanityfair.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Fenit Nirappil / @fenitn: A lot to unpack here, but are the salons of Georgetown supposed to be Unofficial Washington?? https://www.vanityfair.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Robert Allbritton / @r_allbritton: Great piece on the new @politico playbook team. My morning inbox is about to become a lot more fun! https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Ahmed Al Omran / @ahmed: Politico's Playbook generated at least $10 million in 2020 https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Nancy Cook / @nancook: Congrats @RyanLizza, @tarapalmeri, @rachaelmbade and @EugeneDaniels2 — all smart and fun ppl. Looking forward to reading your reinvention of Playbook, esp. Eugene's take — https://twitter.com/...
Mark / @rush_hour1: So excited for my friend @EugeneDaniels2 to take the helms as a co-author of POLITICO Playbook!!! (Expecting many Beyoncé scoops from now on) https://twitter.com/...
Eoin Higgins / @eoinhiggins_: There was a moment there when I thought it was possible Olivia Nuzzi was actually standing up for a variety of views in the discourse, blah blah blah etc, but of course it's much simpler: Her boyfriend is in charge of Playbook now https://twitter.com/...
Lachlan Markay / @lachlan: PLAYBOOK (2021), directed by Wes Anderson https://www.vanityfair.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Jonathan Allen / @jonallendc: Congratulations to all who are taking the helm —> https://twitter.com/...
Ryan Lizza / @ryanlizza: This is gonna be fun... https://twitter.com/...
Justin Baragona / @justinbaragona: .@maxwelltani reported two weeks ago that this was going to be the team that Politico put in place to replace the old Playbook group. https://thedailybeast.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Dan Froomkin / @froomkin: The same @RyanLizza who equated @chrislhayes and @benshapiro only yesterday. https://twitter.com/... (fixed) https://twitter.com/...
Tara Palmeri / @tarapalmeri: It's true! I'm coming back to @politico to write Playbook! excited about the new team @rachaelmbade @RyanLizza @EugeneDaniels2 & bringing some of the old-stye @POLITICO sauce back https://twitter.com/...
Rachael Bade / @rachaelmbade: Some personal news I'm FINALLY able to say out loud: I'm super jazzed to be taking the helm of @playbookplus w/@RyanLizza @EugeneDaniels2 @tarapalmeri More in @joepompeo's @VanityFair https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Seung Min Kim / @seungminkim: The Playbook crew is so darn lucky to have @mikezapler leading them. Forever will be one of my favorite editors https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Jake Sherman / @jakesherman: Congrats to the new Playbook crew!!! very exciting for Politico! https://twitter.com/...
Tara Palmeri / @tarapalmeri: yes I did jump out of helicopter for that photo & I may bring my true crime experience to fight some real crime https://twitter.com/...
Meredith Shiner / @meredithshiner: 1) bummed @MattNegrin isn't listed as “host of hardball on msnbc” here 2) glad I unsubscribed yesterday because I mean, look at this quote where the pastor at Martin Luther King, Jr.'s church is put IN THE SAME SENTENCE as Marjorie Taylor Greene https://www.vanityfair.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Tara Palmeri / @tarapalmeri: Some NEWS! I'm heading home to @POLITICO and plan to “Bring Some of the Old Playbook Back” w/ @RyanLizza @EugeneDaniels2 @rachaelmbade — @Politico's Juicing Up Its Morning Mainstay as Team Biden Comes to Town | @VanityFair https://www.vanityfair.com/...
Lindsey Ellefson / The Wrap: Politico Announces 4 New Writers for Playbook Newsletter
Andrew Beaujon / Washingtonian: Politico Announces Its New Playbook Team
Depressed & Incredulous / @abrowngaywrites: POLITICO publishing a Ben Shapiro piece is a pitch-perfect example of “treating white supremacy as an idea to debate rather than a movement to be defeated.” (Quote attributable to @RottenInDenmark) https://twitter.com/...
Jason Campbell / Media Matters for America: What Politico Playbook didn't tell its readers about Ben Shapiro
RELATED:
Berny Belvedere / Arc Digital:
Politico staffers were upset about Shapiro guest-curating Playbook not because he is a conservative but because he is the apotheosis of culture war excess — Berny Belvedere DISSOLVES THE FLESH of Ben Shapiro's takes through a REVERSE OSMOSIS OF PAIN — Politico invited Ben Shapiro to guest-curate its Playbook newsletter.
Discussion:
@tomzellerjr, @ngrossman81, @sheltondesigner, @brooks_bonny, @jennarmathias, The Rundown, @mattwelch, @trumwill, @sladesr, @ldburnett, @jimswiftdc, @edbott, @mehdirhasan and The Wrap
Discussion:
Tom Zeller Jr / @tomzellerjr: “[@benshapiro] has called for the recovery of something — good-faith disagreement — that his entire career has been meticulously engineered to undermine.” https://arcdigital.media/...
Nicholas Grossman / @ngrossman81: The funniest part is @bernybelvedere's main point in this article is criticizing the popular “manufacturing outrage” type of conservative commentary for crowding out thoughtful conservative commentary and, overall, making discourse worse. https://arcdigital.media/...
Chris Shelton / @sheltondesigner: This is as spot-on a criticism of Ben Shapiro as you'll ever find. If you ever thought there's something wrong with that guy but I can't put my finger on what it is, this'll help clarify what he's been about from the beginning. https://arcdigital.media/...
Bonny Brooks / @brooks_bonny: On how Ben Shapiro's lucrative but deeply disingenuous, shrill style has poisoned the well of political debate. As ever, clear-eyed, illuminating, and funny from @bernybelvedere . Read it. @ArcDigi https://arcdigital.media/...
Jenna Mathias / @jennarmathias: “For every Ben Shapiro or Mark Levin or even Michael J. Knowles, there are a number of other, more thoughtful conservative commentators who simply don't exhaust their creative energies manufacturing outrage at all the things libs say and do.” https://twitter.com/...
Matt Stokes / The Rundown: Towards Renewal — Happy Friday, and thanks for reading! — I know I said the full launch …
Matt Welch / @mattwelch: “there are a number of other, more thoughtful conservative commentators who simply don't exhaust their creative energies manufacturing outrage at all the things libs say and do, and as a result their engagement numbers don't come anywhere near” https://arcdigital.media/...
Will Truman / @trumwill: “Berny Belvedere DISSOLVES THE FLESH of Ben Shapiro's takes through a REVERSE OSMOSIS OF PAIN” https://arcdigital.media/...
@sladesr: “Shapiro is both (a) completely right about this and (b) the embodiment of a style of political commentary responsible for miring us in this muck in the first place.” https://arcdigital.media/...
Dr. Lora Burnett / @ldburnett: I think my friend @bernybelvedere is being too hard on @politico staffers here, and should be harder on Politico editors. BUT his analysis of @benshapiro and how he has poisoned the idea of “good faith debate” is spot on. From @arcdigi https://arcdigital.media/...
Jim Swift / @jimswiftdc: This dek slays https://arcdigital.media/...
Ed Bott / @edbott: “As if a half decade of radioactive discourse chuddery can suddenly be whitewashed, and [Ben] Shapiro sanitized as just your everyday mainstream conservative.” This is quite good. https://arcdigital.media/...
Mehdi Hasan / @mehdirhasan: Politico handed over its Playbook today to Ben Shapiro, who used it to (falsely) accuse Bernie Sanders of inciting the shooting of Steve Scalise and to equate Bernie's rhetoric with Trump's. I kid you not. (h/t @MattNegrin) https://www.politico.com/...
Lindsey Ellefson / The Wrap: Politico Under Fire for Letting Ben Shapiro Guest Edit Newsletter
Maxwell Tani / The Daily Beast:
Some Politico staffers raised concerns internally about the decision to allow Ben Shapiro to guest-write Playbook; editor Matt Kaminski defended the move — Several staffers expressed dismay over handing the keys to the outlet's influential newsletter product to a pundit with a “long history of bigoted and incendiary commentary.”
Discussion:
@erikwemple, @maxwelltani, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @mattnegrin, @willmcavoyacn, Washington Post, @brucebartlett, @benyt, PRESS RUN, @lifesafeast, @sirajahashmi, Washington Post, @surabees, @maxwelltani, @paulkrugman, @jeff_jacoby, @juddlegum, @jayrosen_nyu, @benshapiro, @sabrinasiddiqui, The Media Nut, @abdallah_fayyad, @glcarlstrom, @piersmorgan, @dfriedman33, @jayrosen_nyu, @benyt, @caitleg, @jrubinblogger, @elaheizadi, @marlownyc, @alexkotch, @erikwemple, @samthielman, @arifleischer, @maxkennerly, Le·gal In·sur·rec· tion, @wexler, @nycweboy, @tonydleonardi, @andizeisler, @wajahatali, @davidsirota, @sorayamcdonald, @futterish, @elienyc, @corb_the_lesser, Poynter, The Federalist, @jeremypgordon, @megynkelly, @jbouie, @pwthornton, @soledadobrien, @holmesjosh, @willmcavoyacn, @danpfeiffer, @eugene_scott, @katiehill4ca, @imleor, @clarajeffery, @maxwelltani, @bernybelvedere, @gina_goldberg, @adotsad, @lollardfish, @justin_higgins2, @zac_petkanas, @senhorraposa, @jamisonfoser, @karlitaliliana, @gabby_hoffman, @sarahw, @nberlat, @jon_allsop, @emorwee, @tpcarney, @casmudde, @maxwelltani, @grace_segers, @susanbordson, @onlxn, @russcanread, @alqabadai, @blackamazon, @wagatwe, @kimcrayton1, @elienyc, @sethfriederman, @espiers, @libbycwatson, @erikwemple, @sabrinasiddiqui, @meredithshiner, @froomkin, HuffPost, Mediaite, The Hill, The Right Scoop and Daily Truth Report
Discussion:
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Politico has released a statement on the backlash against using @benshapiro as a guest-writer for Playbook. It says, “we rise above partisanship and ideological warfare.” https://twitter.com/...
Max Tani / @maxwelltani: Politico EIC Matt Kaminski briefly addressed the concerns today, saying the decision to have Shapiro guest author Playbook was part of the publication's commitment to reflecting a range of views https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Just chatted with a pair of @politico staffers who dissent from the prevailing outrage over the @benshapiro guest-hosting gig. They say they didn't speak up on the call because the sentiment is so heated and one-sided.
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: There are now upwards of 225 people on the @politico Zoom call convened to hash out the decision to invite @benshapiro to guest-write an edition of Playbook. People are very mad, I am hearing.
@mattnegrin: I got my start in news at @politico. I would quit on the spot today. Handing their newsletter to a proudly bad-faith Republican to spread this pure shit is the grossest thing I've seen happen there This isn't even part of the “is this journalism” debate. This is just sickening https://twitter.com/...
Will McAvoy / @willmcavoyacn: It's like asking Cookie Monster to write a diet column. https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / Washington Post: Politico's revolt over Ben Shapiro guest-hosting Playbook went too far
@brucebartlett: POLITICO has seriously damaged its brand by letting right-wing asshole Ben Shapiro guest-edit its flagship publication this week. When I saw it I thought it was a joke. Dumb idea. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Ben Smith / @benyt: Politico editor-in-chief Matt Kaminski told staff they're not going to apologize for having Ben Shapiro guest edit Playbook, then listened to staff complaints (esp from Congress team) on an internal call.
Jamie Schler / @lifesafeast: Okay, I'm thinking the whole concept of “balance” and “both sides” is done and over. Propaganda is not opinion. Conspiracy theories is not opinion. Disinformation is not opinion. No ethical or respectable media outlet should give them space. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Siraj Hashmi / @sirajahashmi: you've promoted @benshapiro for years. https://twitter.com/search ✍🏼welcome✍ 🏼back✍🏼to✍ 🏼the✍🏼List✍ 🏼Jen✍🏼 https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Elahe Izadi / Washington Post: Politico brought Ben Shapiro on as a ‘Playbook’ guest author to bring balance. It brought a backlash instead.
Andrew Surabian / @surabees: The collective media meltdown over @benshapiro guest editing playbook has done a really impressive job of reinforcing virtually every conservatives pre-conceived notions about the media. If you're to the right of the Lincoln Project, they don't think your voice should be heard. https://twitter.com/...
Max Tani / @maxwelltani: In response to staff concerns, Kaminski reiterated his perspective about the need for ideological diversity, and has rebuffed suggestions for Politico to apologize: “We're not going to back away from having published something because some people think it was a mistake to do so.”
Paul Krugman / @paulkrugman: Lots of depressing thing out there, but this one is special. A media org looks at a violent attack on Congress and thinks, “Hey, let's be counterintuitive and give a platform to a prominent apologist for extremism.” We may be doomed https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Jeff Jacoby / @jeff_jacoby: Krugman admitted a decade ago that he doesn't read any conservative writers. His idea of a robust political debate is one in which only his side is heard from, and the other side is sneered at as “apologists for extremism.” https://twitter.com/...
Judd Legum / @juddlegum: 1. Here is some information you won't read about in Politico Playbook today. On Jan 5, @benshapiro turned over his “Daily Shapiro Action” email to Ted Cruz. Cruz used the opportunity to push his bogus allegations that the election was invalid. https://twitter.com/...
Jay Rosen / @jayrosen_nyu: Politico brought Ben Shapiro on as a ‘Playbook’ guest author to bring balance. It brought a backlash instead. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... Backlash from their own people, I should add. The editors' view: We're not ideological. We asked Chris Hayes too. What's your problem?
Ben Shapiro / @benshapiro: People losing their s*** over me writing @politico Playbook this morning are pretty much proving my point. So keep at it guys, you're doing great! https://www.politico.com/...
Sabrina Siddiqui / @sabrinasiddiqui: I would appreciate if someone from @politico would read all the racist things Ben Shapiro has said about Arabs and Muslims here and then explain why they chose to give him a platform https://bridge.georgetown.edu/ ...
Josh Sternberg / The Media Nut: Time for media's ‘coalition of conscience’
Abdallah Fayyad / @abdallah_fayyad: This is who Politico gave their platform to today. And the editor in chief refuses to apologize. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Gregg Carlstrom / @glcarlstrom: What everyone needs to register is that the operative distinction in American politics right now isn't between left and right. It's been people who engage in good faith and people who are bad-faith charlatans and grifters happy to poison the well https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Piers Morgan / @piersmorgan: How pathetic. I hope @benshapiro sticks it to these illiberal ‘liberal’ twerps. https://twitter.com/...
Dan Friedman / @dfriedman33: A problem with this take is that Shapiro is dishonest. So he's not an especially helpful interpreter of the far right. “Everyone owns zip ties” is not an earnest explanation of values; it's a dumb troll of mainstream media, schtick performed for his audience's enjoyment. https://twitter.com/...
Jay Rosen / @jayrosen_nyu: Pushing off from left and right to clear editorial space for yourself doesn't make you independent. It makes you a difference splitter, a triangulator. Independent is when you hold to your own standard. It's not Chris Hayes + Ben Shapiro = we rise above. https://twitter.com/...
Ben Smith / @benyt: Specifically, two of the people who spoke were front that team; many others also upset. Others apparently not. https://twitter.com/...
@caitleg: The analogue to Ben Shapiro is not Chris Hayes. It is someone like Cenk Uygur, whom Politico would never deign to give a platform. And the fact they can't make that distinction is a big part of the problem. https://twitter.com/...
@jrubinblogger: Employees are well justified in anger. It's not that he is on the right but that he lies and fans bigotry. Politico giving him a platform is no different than Fox putting Laura Ingraham on air. Shameful. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Elahe Izadi / @elaheizadi: In a tense afternoon meeting attended by over 240 Politico employees, dozens voiced their concerns. “Everyone noted it wasn't that he's a conservative but has a history of bigoted comments,” said one reporter. Some demanded apologies. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Marlow Stern / @marlownyc: strange that politico ceded its newsletter to ben shapiro on the same day his/the daily wire's big movie is premiering? that seems like pretty clear promo to me. anyway, here's more on this mess https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Alex Kotch / @alexkotch: This is brain rot. If you simply want to reflect the views that are out there, you would let a Nazi guest write for you if Nazis were just slightly more prominent than they are today. Utter denial of newsmakers' responsibility to their readers. https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: One staffer in today's meeting @politico over the @benshapiro guest-written Playbook argued that the decision to publish his thoughts complicates frequent conversations with Republicans and conservatives: https://twitter.com/...
@samthielman: It's amazing how people don't realize that if you hire and promote white nationalists, you will lose the far more valuable voices of thoughtful nonwhite people who won't want to be associated with you https://twitter.com/...
Ari Fleischer / @arifleischer: Good statement. But what does it say about the left that they became unglued because Ben Shapiro wrote something, which, if the critics read it, was quite thoughtful. It's stunning the only news rooms some reporters want are news rooms where everyone is just like them. https://twitter.com/...
Max Kennerly / @maxkennerly: TFW u “rise above partisanship and ideological warfare” https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Mary Chastain / Le·gal In·sur·rec· tion: Politico Employees, Leftists Whine Because Ben Shapiro Guest Edited the Politico Newsletter
Nu Wexler / @wexler: Politico can turn Playbook over to anyone they want, but amplifying Shapiro makes it harder for their reporters to criticize politicians and social platforms for spreading racist and anti-Muslim crap.
NYC Weboy / @nycweboy: I get that there's a lot of negative feeling about Shapiro. I think it might be more productive to focus on the content - the Playbook wasn't especially well written, contained little that was news, and didn't seem especially accurate. https://twitter.com/...
Anthony Leonardi / @tonydleonardi: New: @benshapiro explains to @dcexaminer that this reaction proves the point in his article. “The staff at Politico actually proved my point: that the goal for much of the Left is complete ostracization of the Right from cultural and political life” https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Andi Zeisler / @andizeisler: Look just because Ben Shapiro is a tiny leprechaun doesn't mean you can dismiss his bigotry, racism, obtuseness, and commitment to intellectual dishonesty as “mischief making” https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Wajahat Ali / @wajahatali: 👇 I feel bad for the journalists of color who work there. https://twitter.com/...
David Sirota / @davidsirota: The newsletter bankrolled by the fossil fuel industry will not apologize for letting a right-wing zealot guest post mere days after a violent insurrection. Got it. https://twitter.com/...
@sorayamcdonald: If a Black person trafficked in as many lies and bad faith characterizations as Shapiro, they wouldn't be allowed to guest edit a neighborhood newsletter, ffs https://twitter.com/...
Mike Futter / @futterish: This minimizes the misogyny and racism that Ben Shapiro spews. It is Both Sidesism's ultimate form, and we should never forget this. https://twitter.com/...
Elie Mystal / @elienyc: MOREOVER, the fact that they think Chris Hayes is the “both sides” of Ben freaking Shapiro is, again, how white supremacists win. I look forward to the day @politico lets Louis Farrakhan and Mitt Romney edit dueling playbooks.
@corb_the_lesser: @HolmesJosh Why not ask how conservatism got to the point of believing Ben Shapiro should speak for it?
Tom Jones / Poynter: What a week it was. Will it get worse? — We close another tumultuous week with relative calm …
Emily Jashinsky / The Federalist: Politico's Ben Shapiro Freakout Is A Perfect Illustration Of A Much Bigger Problem
Jeremy Gordon / @jeremypgordon: “The backlash is a little strange to observe since we're supposed to represent all respectable voices on the ideological spectrum.” Pretty damning indictment of a lot of things if Shapiro, who is 1000000% full of shit, is a “respectable voice” on the right https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Megyn Kelly / @megynkelly: Grow up, people. https://twitter.com/...
B-Boy Bouiebaisse / @jbouie: @SabrinaSiddiqui @politico Here's hoping they didn't know versus they did know and just didn't care.
Patrick Thornton / @pwthornton: @jbouie @SabrinaSiddiqui @politico To not know that Ben Shapiro is racist is to not know who Ben Shapiro is. They knew. Just didn't care.
Soledad O'Brien / @soledadobrien: ‘We are happy to platform racists and bigots and those who spew disinformation, if we think it will go viral but also not hurt our brand’ Anyway—as I keep telling you guys—Politico is mostly trash. https://twitter.com/...
Josh Holmes / @holmesjosh: It blows my mind how journos insist on validating conservative criticism at every turn. https://twitter.com/...
Will McAvoy / @willmcavoyacn: “Which is why we gave our most visible column to a partisan, racist, sexist, xenophobic, homophobic zealot.” https://twitter.com/...
Dan Pfeiffer / @danpfeiffer: This is a bizarre and non-sensical statement — saying that Politico's brand is being non-partisan is not a great explanation/defense for handing over your flagship product to a discredited partisan on one of the biggest news days in recent memory https://twitter.com/...
Eugene Scott / @eugene_scott: Given this, really interested in who they have lined up as future guest writers ... https://twitter.com/...
Katie Hill / @katiehill4ca: Perhaps if a publication wants to “rise above partisanship and ideological warfare” it shouldn't feature one of the worst perpetrators of said warfare. Just a thought. https://twitter.com/...
Clara Jeffery / @clarajeffery: not sure how you can rise above those things while handing your audience to a person who celebrates those things https://twitter.com/...
Max Tani / @maxwelltani: On the editorial call, staff reaction to Shapiro's Playbook authorship was overwhelmingly negative. Some compared Shapiro to Alex Jones, and said Kaminski was dismissive of concerns. But a few staffers reached out to me to defend the decision (anonymously) https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Berny Belvedere / @bernybelvedere: The most preposterous thing about this reply is it requires flattening conservatism into the person and work of Ben Shapiro. “Oh, you have a problem with Ben? You must want to cancel all of conservatism!” As if Shapiro is basically interchangeable with Ramesh Ponnuru or whoever https://twitter.com/...
@gina_goldberg: if this is considered mainstream conservatism count me out https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@adotsad: One of the things conservatives do really well is take criticism of one of their millionaires/celebrities/politicians etc and pretending its a literal attack on the livelihood of every random conservative in the country. Same shit Trump does, but Shapiro et al do the same thing. https://twitter.com/...
David M. Perry / @lollardfish: This tweet is enough evidence to end Shapiro's access to respectable publications. @politico published a vile bigot as if this kind of thing is just a matter of debate. Which I guess for that outlet's leaders it is. https://twitter.com/...
Justin Higgins / @justin_higgins2: @benyt They picked the worst time to do this with the recent launch of @PunchbowlNews. This will hurt them financially.
Zac Petkanas / @zac_petkanas: There are just conservative voices who aren't openly pro-coup, homophobic, anti-trans and White supremacist. https://twitter.com/...
Drew Savicki / @senhorraposa: They should not have published Ben Shapiro. It does a disservice to Politico by publishing him. Shapiro is deeply Islamophobic and homophobic. He has a long history of racist statements. https://twitter.com/...
Jamison Foser / @jamisonfoser: Saying “we rise above partisanship and ideological warfare” the same day you made Ben Shapiro your guest editor is like claiming to be a law and order president while the mob you incited seizes the Capitol. https://twitter.com/...
Karla Monterroso / @karlitaliliana: If they rise above ideological warfare so much, I wanna see the last 5 op-eds by Black progressive women. https://twitter.com/...
Gabriella Hoffman / @gabby_hoffman: Kudos, @politico . Wish more news outlets would give consideration to other views. Discourse is healthy, debate is necessary, and we all benefit when we can freely read different views in major publications. https://twitter.com/...
Sarah Weinman / @sarahw: what a hill to die on https://twitter.com/...
Noah Berlatsky / @nberlat: why does everyone think that platforming a rabid racist is “rising above” partisanship? maybe it's sinking below partisanship? https://twitter.com/...
Jon Allsop / @jon_allsop: This criticism-proof logic is a big problem in media: if you criticize our conception of political evenhandedness, you are trying to politicize us, thus proving the merit of our conception https://twitter.com/...
Emily Atkin / @emorwee: Love when a news outlet with half its content sponsored by Chevron brags about its “independent journalism” https://twitter.com/...
@casmudde: There is nothing admirable about being “non-partisan” or “neutral” when one party is anti-democratic. @politico https://twitter.com/...
Max Tani / @maxwelltani: Politico just said on this call that the plan is to announce the new Playbook team tomorrow https://twitter.com/...
Grace Segers / @grace_segers: @maxwelltani “mischief making” ?
Susan Bordson / @susanbordson: @maxwelltani Exactly. Politico was recently receiving some praise for its maturing as a publication in positive ways. To then have the poor judgment to provide amplification to THAT guy can't be rationalized as mere pot-stirring.
Owen Ellickson / @onlxn: btw: the safest assumption here is Shapiro got Politico some oil money and they grabbed some other opeds to launder his byline in through “ideological diversity.” might not be what happened, but would love to hear that from Politico!
Russ Read / @russcanread: @brianstelter I sincerely believe that there is a huge portion of Playbook readers who wouldn't even have realized Ben guest edited today if certain folks on Twitter hadn't made such a big deal about it.
Travis Owen / @alqabadai: @RussCanRead @brianstelter That's not really a good thing. It just allows him to launder bullshit claims through the Politico brand with less pushback because people will assume it's reliable.
@blackamazon: I would like coins for the years I spent watching these chuckle muppets do this and be told to calm down . Then I would like to fight some folks https://twitter.com/...
Wagatwe Wanjuki / @wagatwe: This is why Black folks didn't trust any of these white led organizations statements about doing better. Because it's just about not looking bad vs an actual, consistent commitment to not being active tools of white supremacy that'd require true overhaul. https://twitter.com/...
@kimcrayton1: “Mischief making has always been a part of @politico's secret sauce” @KaminskiMK this decision isn't mischief, it's harmful & ur dismissive response is an ex of the role u play in maintaining the systems, institutions & policies of white supremacy https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Elie Mystal / @elienyc: Can't make this up. @politico's official defense for promoting white supremacy is “mischief making.” This is how too many white people think. That allowing white supremacists to tout their views is just... impish. https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Seth Friedermann / @sethfriederman: @ElieNYC @politico I checked twice to make sure there wasn't some other Ben Shapiro. Feels like a cash grab by @politico to me.
Elizabeth Spiers / @espiers: @ElieNYC @politico Feel like I have some authority on the topic of journalistic mischief making and I don't think giving a pint sized squeaky racist the keys to the car qualifies.
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Good piece by @maxwelltani on Politico erupting over @benshapiro guest-hosting Playbook. You know, if you want to hear Shapiro's opinions, there's a place to go for that. https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Sabrina Siddiqui / @sabrinasiddiqui: This is not about a range of views. It's about downplaying and normalizing bigotry toward black, brown, Muslim and LGBTQ people. Understanding that is fundamental to how we got here. And to dismiss it as “mischief making” is as offensive as it is absurd. https://twitter.com/...
Meredith Shiner / @meredithshiner: this is honestly a worse and more deranged justification—and in a more chef's kiss context—than I imagined it would be. https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Dan Froomkin / @froomkin: How as a journalist do you defend giving equal time to people who are making bad-faith arguments and inciting people with misinformation? At Politico, you pat yourself on the back for not taking sides and mischief-making. https://twitter.com/...
Nick Robins-Early / HuffPost: Politico Newsroom In Uproar Over Ben Shapiro's Guest Playbook Column
Marisa Sarnoff / Mediaite: Politico Editors Stand By Ben Shapiro as Playbook Guest Author
Jordan Williams / The Hill: Ben Shapiro stirs controversy by guest writing Politico newsletter
Columbia Journalism Review:
On Wikipedia's 20th anniversary, the need for nuance in reporting about the project is crucial as sites like Breitbart and Russian media try to discredit it — Last year, as the election approached, we heard that the founder of 8chan had become an active Wikipedia editor.
Discussion:
OneZero, @lsanger, @rozzy, @brittagus, @docsoupman, @ozm, @sarahfkessler, @mrpmharrison, @thelma_lutun, @peteforsyth, @alexhern, @abigailb, @marklittlenews, @steviebenton, @raju, @janebsinger, @alanmillernlp, Fast Company, Stephen Harrison's newsletter and The A.V. Club, more at Techmeme »
Discussion:
Tom Roston / OneZero: An Oral History of Wikipedia, the Web's Encyclopedia
Larry Sanger / @lsanger: Anniversary piece on Wikipedia. I was interviewed for it. https://onezero.medium.com/...
Ryan Osborn / @rozzy: “It was radical in the way that it enabled accessibility to publishing on the web and also enabled collaboration.” https://onezero.medium.com/...
Britta Gustafson / @brittagus: It was fun to be interviewed for this Wikipedia history article as an early Wikipedia editor! It's important to tell these stories of when it was just a weird experiment, not yet a huge and complex project essential to a lot of people, to give context for its confusing parts. https://twitter.com/...
Tom Roston / @docsoupman: Happy 20th Birthday, @Wikipedia! Here's my oral history of the “project” by the people who made it happen so far @krmaher @WardCunningham @brittagus @MagnusManske @jimmy_wales @tnegrin @fuzheado https://onezero.medium.com/...
OneZero / @ozm: It's hard to imagine the internet without Wikipedia. At this point, the definitive digital encyclopedia is the default resource for everything and everyone. But it was also never meant to exist — at least, not like this. https://read.medium.com/tLnGC1L
Sarah Kessler / @sarahfkessler: The definitive history of Wikipedia, which is 20 years old this week: https://onezero.medium.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Phil Harrison / @mrpmharrison: I love Wikipedia. One of the last remaining bits of the internet which Tim Berners-Lee could look at without wincing. Happy 20th. https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Thelma Young-Lutunatabua / @thelma_lutun: I really enjoy this article- it shows the ways that Wikipedia has been successful without commercialization. It's a reminder of a way the internet could be. https://twitter.com/...
Pete Forsyth / @peteforsyth: “The media can do more than just call out biases on Wikipedia; it can also help address them.” Wikipedia is twenty. It's time to start covering it better. https://www.cjr.org/... via @cjr
Alex Hern / @alexhern: Wikipedia is one of the seven wonders of the digital world, and I cannot believe it is still alive. A true treasure. https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Abigail Brady / @abigailb: alex quotes me in this. i have a complicated relationship to it as a project, but in the sort of way you get angry at your football team. it's the closest the web has come to achieving its original premise and i'm glad it still exists. https://twitter.com/...
Mark Little / @marklittlenews: Any conversation about what the internet should be starts and often finishes with Wikipedia. Happy Birthday. And thank you. https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Stevie Benton / @steviebenton: Happy 20th birthday to @Wikipedia - quite possibly the greatest achievement of the 21st century, and one of the biggest and boldest collaborations in human history. It shouldn't work. It does. Cherish it. Thank you to @jimmy_wales for getting us going, and to all Wikipedians
Raju Narisetti / @raju: Today, @Wikipedia is twenty. It's well past time for journalists to start covering it better. Here is how https://www.cjr.org/... via @cjr
Jane Singer / @janebsinger: Why does Wikipedia work? Two key reasons. One, it's not a free-for-all: many mechanisms regulate its market of ideas. And two is that its editors are a ‘diverse and often divergent’ community, people who may agree on little except the project's worth. https://www.cjr.org/... @cjr
Alan C. Miller / @alanmillernlp: “Though far from perfect,” @Wikipedia “now seems better poised to offer fact-checking than mainstream and social media.” https://www.cjr.org/... via @cjr
Katherine Maher / Fast Company: In a fragmented reality, Wikipedia isn't just a refuge. It's a roadmap
RELATED:
Alex Pasternack / Fast Company:
A look at the raging debate inside Wikipedia, where neutrality is prized above all, on what to call the attack on the Capitol — ‘Storming’? ‘Insurrection’? ‘Riot’? ‘Attempted coup’? On Wikipedia, where neutrality is prized above all, volunteers are still searching for the words.
Discussion:
The Guardian, @ariannahuff, @krmaher, @martinsfp, @chrisalbon, @luis_in_brief, @bkeegan, @fuzheado, @harrymccracken, @pasternack, @thewikipedian and The Ringer, more at Techmeme »
Discussion:
Alex Hern / The Guardian: Wikipedia at 20: last gasp of an internet vision, or a beacon to a better future?
Arianna Huffington / @ariannahuff: Happy 20th birthday to @Wikipedia, a thriving example of an earlier, more human-centered internet. What's the most recent entry you read? https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Katherine Maher / @krmaher: It's fascinating that we call it @Wikipedia's birthday and give it attributes of life. Yes, we anthropomorphize a website, perhaps because we understand that while it may not be human, it is a record of our humanity — fallible, fragile, brilliant — and in progress. #Wikipedia20 https://twitter.com/...
Martin Sfp Bryant / @martinsfp: “Storming'? ‘Insurrection’? ‘Riot’? ‘Attempted coup’? On Wikipedia, where neutrality is prized above all, volunteers are still searching for the words.” https://www.fastcompany.com/ ...
Chris Albon / @chrisalbon: Not only is it still alive, it is stronger than ever. https://twitter.com/...
Luis Villa / @luis_in_brief: I unironically believe @Wikipedia should be listed by @UNESCO as a World Heritage Site. It is imperfect, but easily beats essentially all other sites so recognizes as the most impressive example of human coordination and potential. And the only one that is truly global. https://twitter.com/...
Dr. Brian Keegan / @bkeegan: Great reporting on how @Wikipedia's article about the 2021 insurrection came together featuring quotes from @molly0xFFF and yours truly. https://www.fastcompany.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Andrew Lih / @fuzheado: As a mob attacked the Capitol, @Wikipedia struggled to find the right words - ‘Storming’? ‘Insurrection’? ‘Riot’? ‘Attempted coup’? Discussion ongoing as reported in @FastCompany @pasternack https://www.fastcompany.com/ ...
Harry McCracken / @harrymccracken: For those of us who mostly use Wikipedia to look up stuff about the past, it's easy to forget that it also covers stuff that's happening right now—which has all sorts of implications. (By @pasternack.) https://www.fastcompany.com/ ...
Alex Pasternack / @pasternack: As rioters invaded the Capitol, Wikipedia's volunteers were already crafting a solid, citation-rich record of events—and behind the scenes, having revealing, rigorous, sometimes raucous debates over language They're still not even sure what to call it https://www.fastcompany.com/ ...
@thewikipedian: Are Another Believer and Gorilla Warfare capital-n Notable yet? I'd say it's close! https://www.fastcompany.com/ ...
Ben Lindbergh / The Ringer: The Fight to Win the Pettiest Edit Wars on Wikipedia
Taylor Lorenz / New York Times:
As Snapchat starts competing with TikTok via its Spotlight program, some creators begin earning small fortunes and look for ways to expand — Top performers are raking in cash as the company seeks to compete against TikTok and similar platforms. — In late November, Cam Casey …
Discussion:
@taylorlorenz, The Information, @oscarwgrut, @taylorlorenz, @jrhennessy, @justupthepike, @tjmanotoc, @yungchomsky, @ahmed, @ahmed, @mathewi, @jowyang, @carnage4life, @kattenbarge, @benschwerin, @nathanblawrence, @sub8u, @kendallostrow, @timmaughan, @taylorlorenz, @nmcalone, @cheriehu42, @taylorlorenz, @sofiargross, @mattnavarra, @kevinbparry, @mtzler, @kerrymflynn, @richlightshed, @taylorlorenz, @taylorlorenz, @taylorlorenz, @taylorlorenz, Variety, @richlightshed, @yashar, contextisking.com, Business Insider and Taylor Lorenz's Newsletter
Discussion:
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Snapchat is paying out $1M a day to ppl who post viral videos to it's new TikTok-like feature, Spotlight. I spoke to some of the users who have won big, making millions of dollars in just a couple weeks. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Oscar Williams-Grut / @oscarwgrut: Why would anyone play the lottery when you have Snapchat spotlight? https://www.nytimes.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Imagine if Twitter started paying millions of $ to people who did the most viral tweets https://twitter.com/...
Henno / @jrhennessy: If you want a vision of the next few years it is “three or four functionally identical content platforms paying absurd sums to poach content creators from one another” https://twitter.com/...
Dan Reed / @justupthepike: A high school student from Olney made $1 million posting Snapchats, a reminder that I was born at the wrong time and am in the wrong business 😬 https://ow.ly/...
@yungchomsky: i will now be pivoting to whatever it is these children do. watch this space https://twitter.com/...
Ahmed Al Omran / @ahmed: A Saudi influencer said in 2019 that he makes $4.8 million in annual revenue by posting sponsored content on Snapchat (this was before the company launched its “Spotlight” feature) https://www.riyadhbureau.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Ahmed Al Omran / @ahmed: A high school student from Maryland has earned over $1 million from Snapchat in the past two months by posting unboxing videos https://www.nytimes.com/...
Mathew Ingram / @mathewi: BRB — going to do a video of me cooking steak in my toaster and make a million dollars https://www.nytimes.com/...
Jeremiah Owyang / @jowyang: Snapchat influencers are earning $100,000... ...PER week. If consistent, that would be $5.2 Million a year. Or, work minimum wage: the US federal minimum wage at full time is about $15k a year New article from @TaylorLorenz https://www.nytimes.com/...
Dare Obasanjo / @carnage4life: Snapchat paying whoever has the viral videos each day thousands of dollars reminds me of the replies under each viral tweet hawking night lights. This is another place where Twitter should formalize emergent behavior on its platform and reward creators. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Kat Tenbarge / @kattenbarge: My new retirement plan is going to be very Snapchat focused https://twitter.com/...
Ben Schwerin / @benschwerin: “I now have the opportunity to go to the school of my choice. For a lot of people Spotlight is going to change their life and it's unbelievable.” https://twitter.com/...
Nathan Lawrence / @nathanblawrence: The question in the background with any big creator compensation scheme, especially one as explosive as this for a new feature, where a company easily eats up half a billion a year sustaining it, is...what happens if this gambit doesn't take off? Where do creators go? https://twitter.com/...
Subrahmanyam Kvj / @sub8u: Universal Basic Income is already here. It's just called user acquisition cost 😉 https://www.nytimes.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Kendall Ostrow / @kendallostrow: Snapchat Spotlight is the first platform to get the creator economy right from the jump. By emphasizing the content instead of the fame/creator, they've made monetization feel possible for everyone, thus increasing adoption exponentially. Incredible reporting from @TaylorLorenz. https://twitter.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Here's some key background and news from the biz side of Snap from @alexeheath to read alongside my story 👇🏻 https://twitter.com/...
Nathan McAlone / @nmcalone: Was struck by how this Snapchat feature feels like a slot machine. Pay a small amount (time/energy) and hope for unpredictable gigantic payout. https://twitter.com/...
Cherie Hu / @cheriehu42: Music is so behind the “creator economy” Snap pays $1M a DAY to creators of viral videos. Some smaller creators have made 5-6 figures in a few weeks. But if your song goes viral tonight, you prob won't see any royalties from it for minimum 2-6 months 🤷🏻♀ ️ https://www.nytimes.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Almost every story I write makes me feel depressed about living in a wild dystopia but sometimes it really hits hard https://www.nytimes.com/...
Sofia Gross / @sofiargross: Beyond thrilled for my mentor, friend and former boss @BenSchwerin. He is a brilliant, strategic and thoughtful leader. Ben has long believed in the importance of civic engagement for Snap since our early days. So much good to come. Congratulations, Ben! https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
Matt Navarra / @mattnavarra: Snapchat is making a lot young creators very rich, very fast. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Kevin Parry / @kevinbparry: I wrote off Snapchat for years - but they seriously are handing out cash. Don't even need an audience. Got $5k from a recent video. Friends have received massive payments ($100k+). https://www.nytimes.com/...
Mike Metzler / @mtzler: I spoke with @TaylorLorenz about Snapchat Spotlight for the @nytimes! It's crazy, Snapchat has momentum in the creator community that they haven't had since 2015. Everyone and their mom will be talking about Spotlight a week from now. https://www.nytimes.com/...
@kerrymflynn: Great read by @TaylorLorenz on Snapchat Spotlight: https://www.nytimes.com/... “I now have the opportunity to go to the school of my choice. For a lot of people Spotlight is going to change their life and it's unbelievable.” - Katie Feeney, 18, a high school senior in Olney, Md https://twitter.com/...
Rich Greenfield / @richlightshed: 🚨 19-year old has made nearly $3 million from @snapchat's #spotlight 🔥 the creator momentum to snapchat is a very big deal for platform engagement and ultimately monetization $SNAP great piece from @TaylorLorenz @nytimes https://www.nytimes.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Five years later, it's a total 180, payment from a platform is expected. As @josephpalbanese said, TikTok “put all other platforms on notice.” https://www.nytimes.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: The amount of money people are earning overnight is insane. Anyone 16+ is eligible, but if you're under 18 your parents have to approve the payment from Snapchat https://www.nytimes.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Cam Casey, a 19 year old TikTok star, made $3M on Snapchat in under 5 weeks. His roommate, Joey Rogoff, 21, also a TikTok star, made over $1M in the same time. They're just a couple of many raking in massive amounts of cash https://www.nytimes.com/...
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Unlike the TikTok creator fund, you don't have to opt into Snapchat's Spotlight program. One woman who works as an associate at Lowe's for $12.50/hr made half a million dollars for posting a viral video of her sister deep frying a turkey on Thanksgiving https://www.nytimes.com/...
Todd Spangler / Variety: Snap Promotes Ben Schwerin to Head of Content and Partnerships
Rich Greenfield / @richlightshed: So excited for @BenSchwerin — great move @evanspiegel — this is great news for @Snapchat $SNAP 🔥🔥🔥 Scoop via @alexeheath @theinformation https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
Yashar Ali / @yashar: NEWS Snap has promoted @BenSchwerin to be its new senior vice president of content and partnerships, a move that signals the company's ambitions to compete more aggressively with TikTok and to cut more deals with media companies and app developers https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
Ashkan Karbasfrooshan / contextisking.com: What Snap Got Right in the Video Wars
The Information:
Sources: Apple is discussing launching a new subscription service that would charge people to listen to podcasts — Apple—long considered the sleeping giant in the podcast space—is waking up. The company, which runs the most widely used podcasting app in the industry …
Discussion:
Martin Sfp Bryant / @martinsfp: *remembers the outcry when Luminary paywalled podcasts* https://twitter.com/...
Chris Messina / @chrismessina: Amazon vs Apple in the podcast #rundle/#StreamingWars is the battle royale I'm here for. https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
M.G. Siegler / @mgsiegler: Last week, Twitter banning Trump caused Libertarians to call for private enterprise to be regulated. This week, Apple putting podcasts behind paywalls will cause podcast OGs (most of whom are also Apple fans) to say now this is a good thing. Same energy. https://twitter.com/...
Alex Kantrowitz / @kantrowitz: Ah yes, that moment once every five years when Apple remembers it has a podcast app https://twitter.com/...
Obi-Wan Pirillo / @chrispirillo: how about a podcast service that listens to all the podcasts that get podcasted and then pumps out a podcast digestcast pod https://twitter.com/...
@theinformation: Exclusive: @Apple is in talks to launch a subscription podcast offering that would compete with startup Luminary and potentially threaten the podcasting ambitions of big companies like @Spotify and @amazon https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
Rich Greenfield / @richlightshed: Apple launching podcast subscription service was #11 on LightShed's #Top21for21 $AAPL @theinformation reporting it is happening today 👇🔥 https://lightshedtmt.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Jessica Lessin / @jessicalessin: Smart. Inevitable. Great scoop from @jtoonkel https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
Bill Bishop / @niubi: Apple Plans Podcasting Subscription Service in Threat to Spotify https://www.theinformation.com/ ... via @theinformation why not a newsletter subscription service too?
Joshua Benton / @jbenton: Both expected and “whoa”: Apple Plans Podcasting Subscription Service in Threat to Spotify https://www.theinformation.com/ ...
Will Daniel / Business Insider: Spotify sinks 7% after Apple announces plans for podcasting subscription service
Matthew Keys / The Desk: Apple said to be planning premium podcast service
Brandon Russell / XDA Developers: Apple reportedly eyeing subscription podcast service
Mike Peterson / AppleInsider: Apple considering premium podcast service to compete with Amazon, Spotify
Juli Clover / MacRumors: Apple Developing Podcast Subscription Service to Better Compete With Spotify
William Turvill / Press Gazette:
Q&A with Pranay Prabhat, senior director of digital ad tech at NYT, about its new first-party data ad program, losing third-party cookie revenue, and more — From the outside, it may appear that advertising is now insignificant for the New York Times when compared with its soaring digital subscriptions business.
RELATED:
Paul Bennun / KCRW:
California public radio station KCRW drops The Daily, over concerns about NYT's handling of issues surrounding Caliphate
California public radio station KCRW drops The Daily, over concerns about NYT's handling of issues surrounding Caliphate
Discussion:
@kcrw, The Independent, @awalkerinla, @kausmickey, @mollydacious, @sorayanelson, @akmcglinchy, @thebenbergman, @nwquah, KUT Radio … and @reblavoie
Discussion:
@kcrw: KCRW joined with 26 fellow public media organizations in co-signing a letter to The New York Times, concerning issues surrounding its audio productions, including Caliphate and The Daily. Ultimately, KCRW has decided to cease airing The Daily: https://www.kcrw.com/...
Justin Vallejo / The Independent: NYT to reassign reporter hoaxed by Isis ‘con-artist’ in flagship Caliphate podcast
Alissa Walker / @awalkerinla: This was the move to make. Thanks to KCRW for doing the right thing. https://twitter.com/...
Mickey Kaus / @kausmickey: “In order to maintain our journalistic standards KCRW has decided to discontinue the program ...” https://twitter.com/...
Molly Peterson / @mollydacious: “We have concerns about how the Times has handled the aftermath of the erroneous reporting in its audio series Caliphate, which was featured on The Daily, and what this revealed about practices in their audio team.” https://twitter.com/...
SorayaSarhaddiNelson / @sorayanelson: Good call by @kcrw, deciding to cease airing The Daily from The New York Times. https://www.kcrw.com/...
Audrey McGlinchy / @akmcglinchy: As of today, @KUT has pulled The Daily from our airwaves. https://twitter.com/...
Ben Bergman / @thebenbergman: KCRW becomes the second station to drop The Daily, after Houston Public Media. https://twitter.com/...
Nick Quah / @nwquah: KCRW is dropping The Daily from its broadcast schedule i believe this is the second station to do so https://www.kcrw.com/...
Erin Geisler / KUT Radio, Austin's NPR Station: KUT Statement on “The Daily”
Janko Roettgers / Protocol:
Remote controls of new TVs show how streaming services and tech giants are vying for users' attention through branded buttons and voice assistants — Don't touch that dial: As TV manufacturers are unveiling their 2021 models at this year's virtual CES, they're also giving us a first look …
Jim VandeHei / Axios:
Axios publishes a new Bill of Rights: no opinion section ever, most content free for all people, staff pledge to not take public political positions, more — Axios is expanding into local news this month, and broadening our mission to help restore trust in fact-based news with an audience Bill of Rights.
Discussion:
@caseynewton, @film_girl, @hondanhon, @film_girl, @film_girl, @kimlisagor, @film_girl, @paulconstant, @fpmarconi, @karenspringen, @qjurecic, @ndiakopoulos, @taylorlorenz, @juliewestfall, @jayrosen_nyu, @charlesforelle, @bensherwood, @matt_pressman, @mlcalderone, @heidilegg, @mikeallen, Nieman Lab, @jimvandehei and The Fix
Discussion:
Casey Newton / @caseynewton: “We will never have an opinion section” is a good and surprisingly contrarian take, and also something that I think will build trust with readers. (As long as reporters are still empowered to say what they actually think.) https://www.axios.com/...
@film_girl: Also, and I say this with the immense privilege (and it's a privilege I don't expect to always have) of working for a company that doesn't dictate how I express my public opinions (I'm asked not to be dumb, which, fair), I think it's OK to ask people not to tweet
Dan Hon / @hondanhon: Thought experiment: what would it take for an org like the NYT to not only publish this but stick by it? https://www.axios.com/...
@film_girl: I've worked as a journalist at places where I was asked not to take a public position and where I wasn't. I see benefits to both approaches, but it definitely gets sticky when *everything* becomes political.
Christina Warren / @film_girl: This is interesting. I'm not opposed to asking employees to abstain from taking public positions on political topics, but I wonder what counts as political? https://www.axios.com/...
Kim Lisagor Bisheff / @kimlisagor: No reporter-bots, no opinion section, no privacy games, more transparency. This is how you start to restore public trust. https://www.axios.com/...
@film_girl: But for employees — journalists or otherwise — who have large platforms that existed before (and will exist after) their current job, it is equally OK to ask to be compensated in exchange for shutting up. Again, this is a privileged position, I'm deeply aware. But just saying.
Paul Constant / @paulconstant: Some of these are fantastic, but I hate that news orgs still pretend objectivity is a desirable goal. “All employees are asked to refrain from taking/advocating for public positions on political topics” isn't the home run you think it is, Axios. https://www.axios.com/...
Francesco Marconi / @fpmarconi: Luddites: Axios believes that the way to restore trust in news is to eliminate automation, but AI is the only way we can truly establish *ground truth* and measure the world at scale. https://twitter.com/...
Karen Springen / @karenspringen: I'm a little obsessed with reading @axios newsletters! I also like the Axios “bill of rights.” https://www.axios.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Quinta Jurecic / @qjurecic: My t-shirt etc https://www.axios.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Nick Diakopoulos / @ndiakopoulos: Axios Bill of Rights takes aim at AI-written stories, bots, and fake accounts: https://www.axios.com/... via @NickHagar — IMO doesn't make sense to dismiss all AI-written news in the name of “winning the war for truth”.
Taylor Lorenz / @taylorlorenz: Axios formatted its new Bill of Rights into Instagram cards for u https://www.axios.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Julie Westfall / @juliewestfall: What's a political position? It doesn't say. Is supporting mask wearing? Is pointing out anti-democratic behavior? Who decides what a political position is? https://twitter.com/...
Jay Rosen / @jayrosen_nyu: Hmmm. This week Axios introduced an “audience bill of rights.” https://www.axios.com/... An interesting document. It commits to never having an opinion section, and supporting local news, among other promises. “Please hold us accountable for living up to our obligations to you.”
Charles Forelle / @charlesforelle: Disagree with the “no-AI” piece. We are experimenting with AI/NLP for some financial-markets text. Humans are great at analysis and talking to people to figure out why a thing is happening. But there are routine tasks a computer can do more efficiently—and better for readers. https://twitter.com/...
Ben Sherwood / @bensherwood: “Nothing matters more than winning the war for truth.” Great respect for @Axios @JimVandeHei @mikeallen, their new Bill of Rights and vital mission. https://www.axios.com/...
Matthew Pressman / @matt_pressman: The best part about @axios's “bill of rights” is the link to the page explaining “how we make money.” Every publication (and social media platform!) should have this. https://www.axios.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Michael Calderone / @mlcalderone: Axios vows to “never have an opinion section” among its pledges in new audience Bill of Rights https://www.axios.com/...
Heidi Legg / @heidilegg: WOW. @JimVandeHei this is formidable. Journalism is about context. Great news. Our promises to you: Axios Bill of Rights https://www.axios.com/...
Mike Allen / @mikeallen: 🗽 As @Axios expands into local news, we're broadening our mission to help restore trust in fact-based news with an audience Bill of Rights, unveiled here by @Axios CEO @JimVandeHei https://www.axios.com/...
Sarah Scire / Nieman Lab: Axios promises it will never have an opinion section, and more, in an “audience Bill of Rights”
Eva Mathews / Reuters:
Tencent Music acquires China-based Lazy Audio, which provides audiobooks, podcasts, and radio shows, for $417M — (Reuters) - China's Tencent Music Entertainment Group said on Friday it acquired audiobook platform Lazy Audio, owned by Shenzhen Lanren Online Technology Co, for 2.7 billion yuan ($417 million).