Top News:
Washington Post:
Elon Musk takes over Twitter and fires several top executives, including CEO Parag Agrawal, CFO Ned Segal, and policy head Vijaya Gadde — Musk's $44 billion deal to acquire the social media company closed on Thursday night. — SAN FRANCISCO — Elon Musk became Twitter's owner late Thursday …
Discussion:
@elonmusk, New York Times, @mmasnick, @nedsegal, Axios, @whey_standard, New York Times, CNBC, Techdirt, @thierrybreton, CNET, Insider, The Guardian, The Atlantic, CNN, Media Matters for America, Reuters, New York Magazine, New York Times, Bloomberg, TechCrunch, @mattzeitlin, The Hill, MediaPost, Observer, Slate, The Daily Wire, Variety, Mediaite, Fortune, Wall Street Journal, The Register, Jezebel, @ariehkovler, Protocol, Bloomberg, Reason, The Information, Wired, CBS News, Broadband TV News, @donwinslow, MacRumors, Gizmodo, @ericrweinstein, @tinch, Common Dreams, @film_girl, @jason_kint, @_lokeshsharma, Al Jazeera, The Addition, Variety, @kaalateetham, @megan, @nickbilton, @geoffreyvs, The Week, @karaswisher, @mattzeitlin, @quinncy, ABC7, @megbasham, @carnage4life, @dellcam, @jeffjarvis, @goldman, @penamerica, @danprimack, @clarajeffery, Politico, AppleInsider, Agence France-Presse, BuzzFeed News, Vanity Fair, CNET, CNN, The Hollywood Reporter, The Wrap, TechCrunch, The Desk, New York Post, Engadget, WFLA-TV, The Wildfire Newsletter, The Verge, The Daily Beast, Rolling Stone and The New Normal, more at Techmeme »
Discussion:
Elon Musk / @elonmusk: the bird is freed
Mike Masnick / @mmasnick: People do not realize how much @vijaya did for free speech. Twitter is less of a free speech platform without her. https://twitter.com/...
Ned Segal / @nedsegal: Thursday concluded 5 years @twitter. I'm grateful for the opportunity to have worked with such an incredible group of people building the world's town square for all of our stakeholders. The work isn't complete, but we made meaningful progress.
@whey_standard: Oh wow, Musk fired Vijaya. I don't really care about a lot of things on here but I probably will lower my footprint here knowing she's gone. She put a lot of legal heft into protecting user anonymity in court. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Kate Conger / New York Times: Musk Said to Begin Firing Twitter's Top Executives
Mike Masnick / Techdirt: Elon Musk's First Move Is To Fire The Person Most Responsible For Twitter's Strong Free Speech Stance
Thierry Breton / @thierrybreton: 👋 @elonmusk In Europe, the bird will fly by our 🇪🇺 rules. #DSA https://twitter.com/...
Katie Collins / CNET: Europe Warns Twitter's Elon Musk: The Bird Flies by Our Rules
Grace Kay / Insider: Fired Twitter CFO, who's getting a $25.4 million golden parachute, says 'the past 6 months have pulled on every mental muscle I've developed in 48 years'
Charlie Warzel / The Atlantic: How Elon Musk Could Actually Kill Twitter
Media Matters for America: Twitter is now on a glide path to becoming a supercharged engine of radicalization
Margaret Hartmann / New York Magazine: Welcome to Elon Musk's Twitter
Lauren Hirsch / New York Times: Twitter Files to Pull Shares From Stock Market as Elon Musk Moves In
Matthew Zeitlin / @mattzeitlin: parag agrawal secured the bag for his shareholders and got fired, they should build a statue of him in the shareholder value hall of fame
Gianna Melillo / The Hill: Here are the executives that have exited Twitter
Karlene Lukovitz / MediaPost: Musk ‘Reassures’ Advertisers And Employees, Closes Twitter Deal, Cans Top Execs
Sissi Cao / Observer: Elon Musk Officially Became Twitter's Owner and Fired Most of its C-Suite Executives
Alex Kirshner / Slate: Elon Musk Is Already Firing Twitter Executives. Will He Break the Whole Thing?
Ryan Saavedra / The Daily Wire: Leftists Fume After Musk Takes Over Twitter: 'It's Like The Gates Of Hell Opened On This Site'
Todd Spangler / Variety: Elon Musk's Close of $44 Billion Twitter Takeover Confirmed by Stock Delisting Notice
Jackson Richman / Mediaite: Blue Checks FREAK OUT Over Elon Musk Taking Over Twitter: ‘About to Unleash the Nazis’
Tristan Bove / Fortune: Elon Musk to Twitter executives: You're fired, you may now collect $122 million
Lindsay Clark / The Register: Elon Musk jettisons Twitter leadership, says takeover was ‘to try to help humanity’
Susan Rinkunas / Jezebel: Elon Musk Has Already Fired the Woman Behind Twitter Banning Trump
Arieh Kovler / @ariehkovler: The typical Twitter ban isn't Donald Trump. The typical ban is for posting death threats, people's phone numbers and home addresses, and of course the mass scams Musk claims to be fighting. https://twitter.com/...
Issie Lapowsky / Protocol: Elon Musk's reign begins. What happens next?
Elizabeth Nolan Brown / Reason: Musk Says He Bought Twitter ‘To Help Humanity,’ Pledges Not To Let It Become a ‘Free-for-All Hellscape’
Chris Stokel-Walker / Wired: Elon Musk's Twitter Will Be Chaos
Julian Clover / Broadband TV News: Musk finally takes Twitter for $44 billion
Don Winslow / @donwinslow: ANOTHER thing the “experts” assured you would fall through and not happen. https://twitter.com/...
Tim Hardwick / MacRumors: Elon Musk Completes $44 Billion Twitter Takeover, Fires Top Executives, and Makes Himself CEO
Eric Weinstein / @ericrweinstein: Testing, testing. 1-2-3....Is this thing back on again? https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Jake Johnson / Common Dreams: ‘Dangerous for Us All’: Elon Musk, World's Richest Man, Completes Twitter Takeover
Chriscreama Warren / @film_girl: Lol. All the Parag defenders are hilarious. Every single person I have talked to who has worked with him has said without exception that he is a terrible leader. Might be a good engineer. No clue. But a terrible leader. There was a talent drain before Elon.
Jason Kint / @jason_kint: Losing her was an incredibly bad move for leadership and democracy. CEO and CFO... I get it. But she was a hero for civil society. https://twitter.com/...
Charlotte Henry / The Addition: What Elon Musk's Twitter Takeover Might Mean For Free Speech
Todd Spangler / Variety: Elon Musk Closes Twitter Deal, Fires CEO, CFO and Other Top Execs
DR Jagadish J Hiremath / @kaalateetham: Elon Musk's Twitter ownership begins with firings, uncertainty CEO @paraga & CFO Ned Segal escorted out of Twitter HQ. Most controversial Anti India & Anti Hindu @vijaya also removed from her post. Hope we see similar cleaning in @TwitterIndia soon. https://www.reuters.com/...
Megan McCarthy / @megan: It's not over until the Fail Whale returns
Nick Bilton / @nickbilton: Most companies see CEO turnover once every 7 to 15 years. Twitter has now had three different CEOs in the past three years.
Geoffrey Skelley-ton / @geoffreyvs: Honestly, Twitter dying would probably be great for my work-life balance. I'd miss it, though. https://twitter.com/...
Kara Swisher / @karaswisher: Truth. @paraga may be a fired ceo but he lifted Elon's wallet on the way out for shareholders. https://twitter.com/...
Matthew Zeitlin / @mattzeitlin: also big w for the chancery court, signed merger agreements still mean something
Megan Basham / @megbasham: Four top executive heads already roll at Twitter, including CEO and policy head, who set content moderation policy. So all the people who made the decisions to ban Trump and suppress Covid “misinformation” and the Hunter Biden laptop story. https://www.bloomberg.com/...
Dare Obasanjo / @carnage4life: Parag made shareholders a ton of money by selling the company for at least 2x what it was worth in a down market while pocketing a cool eight figures for less than a year of work. This is hall of fame CEO stuff. https://twitter.com/...
Dell Cameron / @dellcam: after @paraga decided inciting violence on Twitter was fine so long as it was directed at trans kids, schools & children's hospitals, i stopped imagining this site could get any worse with him gone. so long guy. https://twitter.com/...
Jeff Jarvis / @jeffjarvis: The sun is dark. Elon Musk completes Twitter takeover and fires top executives https://www.axios.com/...
Jason Goldman / @goldman: I never had the fortune to work with @vijaya but she did more to improve twitter's policies than anyone who ever worked there. As someone who made them worse I'm very grateful for her tenure.
@penamerica: Elon Musk became #Twitter's new owner on Thursday, immediately firing top executives including CEO Parag Agrawal and CFO Ned Segal, who he accused of misleading him over the number of fake accounts on the social media platform. #TwitterTakeover https://www.reuters.com/...
Dan Primack / @danprimack: No surprises in any of the exec firings, no matter if you feel they're justified or not. His texts showed his lack of respect for Parag, despite Jack's pleas, and he said he wanted to be CEO for now. He already had publicly attacked Vijaya's decisions.
Clara Jeffery / @clarajeffery: “The billionaire expects to double revenue within three years, a person familiar with the matter said last week” Such claims, esp via “a person” should be reported with skepticism https://www.bloomberg.com/...
Rebecca Kern / Politico: Musk owns Twitter — and Washington awaits Trump's return
Katie Notopoulos / BuzzFeed News: The Deal Is Done: Elon Musk Finally Owns Twitter
Charlotte Klein / Vanity Fair: It's Happening: Elon Musk Officially Runs Twitter
Queenie Wong / CNET: Elon Musk Reportedly Takes Over Twitter, Fires Executives
Alex Weprin / The Hollywood Reporter: Elon Musk's Twitter Era Begins, Setting Stage for Reboot of Social Platform
Sharon Knolle / The Wrap: Elon Musk Takes Over Twitter, Fires CEO, CFO and Legal Head
Amanda Silberling / TechCrunch: Elon Musk fired top Twitter execs including CEO, reports say
Matthew Keys / The Desk: Elon Musk closes Twitter purchase, fires executives
Karissa Bell / Engadget: Elon Musk has begun his takeover of Twitter
Rebecca Klar / WFLA-TV: Musk officially closes Twitter deal: reports
Kyle Becker / The Wildfire Newsletter: Elon Musk's Buyout Deal of Twitter Has Officially CLOSED, Twitter Execs Have Left Building and ‘Will Not Be Returning’
Elizabeth Lopatto / The Verge: Twitter is now an Elon Musk company
Charisma Madarang / Rolling Stone: Welcome to the ‘Hellscape’: Elon Musk Takes Over Twitter, Fires Top Executives
Michael P Senger / The New Normal: Elon Musk to Become Twitter CEO, Reverse Lifetime Bans
RELATED:
Todd Spangler / Variety:
Elon Musk pens an open letter to calm Twitter advertisers, arguing his goal is not “to make more money” and the service “cannot become a free-for-all hellscape” — Mega-billionaire Elon Musk, nearing the finish line in his rocky takeover of Twitter …
Discussion:
@elonmusk, New York Times, Insider, MediaPost, @sep, Insider, Press Gazette, TechCrunch, Washington Post, The Information, NPR, CNBC, Bloomberg, Today's Take, Forbes, @cwarzel, @daveyalba, WISC-TV, Billboard, New York Post, The Verge, Fortune, Wired, Axios, @wajahatali, @schmittnyc, @bcappelbaum, @miblogestublog, @mzhemingway, KTLA, @adriennelaf, @emilybell, The Shortcut, Bloomberg, @maxkennerly, @hayskali, Pirate Wires, @greg_price11, @vprasadmdmph, @jayrosen_nyu, AdExchanger, Associated Press, Digiday, The Daily Wire, @marklittlenews, @schwarz, @schwarz, @briannawu, Los Angeles Times, @esqueer_, @adriennelaf, @justinhendrix, @pkafka, @goldman, @cwarzel, 9to5Mac, @donie, @ruthbenghiat, FOX News Radio, MAGA Underground, Vox, @theplumlinegs, @oneunderscore__, The Daily Beast, CBS News, @robinw, Vanity Fair, Media Matters for America, Reuters, Music Ally, The Drum, The Hill, Mumbrella, Tech Flash, Mediaite, Politico, Engadget, Slate, Rolling Stone, PC Gamer and Financial Times, more at Techmeme »
Discussion:
Mia Jankowicz / Insider: Conservatives and anti-vaxxers are frantically lobbying Elon Musk to lift Twitter bans on their idols after he took over
Maarten Albarda / MediaPost: Dear Elon... You don't know me, but I am a consumer of your products.
Sarah Personette / @sep: Had a great discussion with @elonmusk last evening! Our continued commitment to brand safety for advertisers remains unchanged. Looking forward to the future! https://twitter.com/...
Charlotte Tobitt / Press Gazette: Unanswered questions for news industry after Elon Musk's Twitter buyout
Darrell Etherington / TechCrunch: Elon Musk owns Twitter: The story so far
Juliana Kim / NPR: Ye appears to be back on Twitter after Elon Musk's takeover
Today's Take: Today's Take - October 28 — Elon Musk wasted no time firing top brass at Twitter as he officially took over the company today.
Nicholas Reimann / Forbes: Video Of Elon Musk Carrying Sink Through Twitter Headquarters Is This Week's Most Popular Tweet
Charlie Warzel / @cwarzel: There is a real ‘end times’ vibe on this site now. So I talked to some smart people about how Twitter could *actually* die under Musk. Enjoy these nightmare scenarios https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Davey Alba / @daveyalba: Key point on Elon's takeover of Twitter and so-called free speech from @sarahfrier: “There's no commercial viability for a network that doesn't have some level of content moderation.” No such thing as a true free-for-all when you're running a business!! https://www.bloomberg.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Erik Gordon / WISC-TV: Elon Musk is poised to take Twitter private. Here's what that means for the company and its future success
Marc Schneider / Billboard: Elon Musk Takes Control of Twitter — What's Next?
Ariel Zilber / New York Post: Elon Musk takes over as Twitter CEO, reportedly plans to lift lifetime bans
Alice Hearing / Fortune: ‘More chaotic and addictive...or unusable’: Twitter users flock to mull life under Musk's rule
Vittoria Elliott / Wired: Elon Musk Now Owns Twitter
Wajahat Ali / @wajahatali: Bad for democracy. Great for white nationalists, trolls and hate-mongers. Stick around and don't cede the space. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Rob Schmitt / @schmittnyc: Inject it into my veins https://twitter.com/...
Binyamin Appelbaum / @bcappelbaum: Status update: Reading the new and improved Twitter as my Tesla drives itself through a hyperloop tunnel. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Adrienne LaFrance / @adriennelaf: “I am fully convinced that if Musk does what he is saying he will do, it will be an absolute shitshow.” https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Emily Bell / @emilybell: A lot to process re Twitter takeover, but mainly extremely sorry for the many good people who work there. Many were heavily invested in trying to make this a better communications platform - that work needs to continue but perhaps now won't https://www.nytimes.com/...
Adam Vjestica / The Shortcut: Elon Musk outlines his vision for Twitter in an open letter to advertisers
Alex Barinka / Bloomberg: The Bright Spot In Social Media's Week of Chaos
Max Kennerly / @maxkennerly: Firing the whole C-suite isn't surprising; the premise of any leveraged buyout is a belief the company is seriously mismanaged. But there are indeed very serious risks of harm to others if he slashes too deep too quickly. Chesterton's fence and all that. https://twitter.com/...
Kali Hays / @hayskali: Twitter engineering teams are being told “bring code” for meetings suddenly scheduled this evening with Elon Musk for tomorrow. Meanwhile, the C-suite is now gone. https://www.businessinsider.com/ ...
Mike Solana / Pirate Wires: Elon Musk Has Taken Twitter: Day Zero
Greg Price / @greg_price11: It really happened. It's here. The absolute mad lad did it. Welcome to a new era of the internet. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
@vprasadmdmph: I agree with Elon that Twitter has great potential. They censored and down-throttled things they should not have during the pandemic. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Jay Rosen / @jayrosen_nyu: “Completing the deal was a victory for Twitter's board.” https://www.nytimes.com/... I would not state that as a natural fact. But from a certain point-of-view, sure. Victory.
Associated Press: ‘The bird has been freed’: Musk ushers in the new Twitter era after taking control and firing 3 top execs
Ryan Saavedra / The Daily Wire: Tesla Engineers Take Control Of Twitter's Algorithms Away From Twitter's Engineers: ‘The Bird Is Freed’
Mark Little / @marklittlenews: “If Twitter dies at the hands of this billionaire, the cause is likely to be tragically banal—neglect” https://twitter.com/...
@schwarz: “It is important to the future of civilization to have a common digital town square.” This would be the traditional kind of town square that's owned by one guy and funded by huge corporate advertisers. https://twitter.com/...
@schwarz: “There has been much speculation about why I bought Twitter. Most of it has been wrong.” I love that Elon Musk believes everyone's forgotten that he tried desperately to not buy Twitter. The reason he did buy it is because he was about to be forced to. https://twitter.com/...
Brianna Wu / @briannawu: This is a very smart piece about how Twitter could die under Musk. None of these are farfetched. https://twitter.com/...
Los Angeles Times: Twitter employees brace for massive layoffs as Elon Musk completes his acquisition
Alejandra Caraballo / @esqueer_: I think this tips their hand to the biggest threat to Twitter now, advertiser flight. Civil rights and anti-hate speech orgs need to put immense pressure on digital advertisers to ensure that meaningful moderations stays in place. Advertisers don't want ads next to hate speech. https://twitter.com/...
Adrienne LaFrance / @adriennelaf: In which @cwarzel subtweets (sub-ledes?) me and @robinsonmeyer https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Justin Hendrix / @justinhendrix: Mudge disclosures suggested Twitter is held together with twigs and duct tape. So this @goldman comment is all the more salient. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Peter Kafka / @pkafka: Ah there we go. https://twitter.com/...
Jason Goldman / @goldman: Was happy to talk to Charlie for this. People dramatically overestimate the resilience of web platforms. Even at companies as bullet proof as Google. Ask people about modifying GWS back in the day and you'll quickly realize how fragile a lot of what we take for granted truly is. https://twitter.com/...
Charlie Warzel / @cwarzel: The piece is really about what & who keeps a platform running. We think of them as massive, often robust companies (and they are to a degree) but they are also very fragile ecosystems, manned by human beings (the kind Musk might fire in large numbers) https://www.theatlantic.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Filipe Espósito / 9to5Mac: Elon Musk officially takes over as Twitter CEO and fires company executives
Donie O'Sullivan / @donie: Interesting to see what Twitter execs publicly embrace Musk. #OneTeam https://twitter.com/...
Ruth Ben-Ghiat / @ruthbenghiat: Nice statement but if he allows people who have incited hate or tried to overthrow a government back on Twitter then these words are just about keeping ad revenue. https://twitter.com/...
John Toldi / FOX News Radio: “Chief Twit” Elon Musk Fires Twitter Executives, Offers Advertisers Olive Branch
Sara Morrison / Vox: What happens to your Twitter data when Elon takes over
Greg Sargent / @theplumlinegs: “Twitter obviously cannot become a free-for-all hellscape,” says Musk now. This essentially concedes that “free speech absolutism” is bunk, which is exactly what many of us have been arguing for months, earning nothing but sneering contempt from Musk's following. https://twitter.com/...
Ben Collins / @oneunderscore__: Brand safety for advertisers! How about them users though? https://twitter.com/...
Matt Wilstein / The Daily Beast: 'Daily Show's' Trevor Noah Mocks Elon Musk's ‘Embarrassing’ Twitter Takeover
Robin Wheeler / @robinw: To all of our partners out there. Thank you for standing by us. Makes me proud to share the below about our future with brand safety. https://twitter.com/...
Bess Levin / Vanity Fair: Elon Musk Wants You to Put Him in the Same Category as Nelson Mandela and Gandhi
Media Matters for America: These top advertisers can stop Musk's Twitter from supercharging online radicalization
Webb Wright / The Drum: Elon Musk says ‘Twitter aspires to be the most respected advertising platform’
Shehab Ahamed / Tech Flash: Tech Flash - 02 — Elon Musk: Twitter Won't Become a ‘Free-for-All Hellscape’ …
Alex Griffing / Mediaite: Elon Musk Walks Back Making Twitter an Absolute Free Speech Zone: ‘Cannot Become a Free-For-All Hellscape’
Wilhelmine Preussen / Politico: EU Commissioner to Elon Musk: Twitter will play by our rules
Wall Street Journal:
Sources: ahead of Elon Musk's takeover, advertisers on Twitter are concerned about looser content moderation and potential conflicts of interest for car ads — Marketers worry about the Tesla CEO's stance on content moderation, potential conflicts in auto advertising if the Twitter deal completes
Discussion:
The Verge, Washington Post, TechCrunch, The Wrap, MediaPost, The Atlantic, New York Post, Insider, Los Angeles Times, CBS News, ZDNet, NPR, @dropkiwifarms, @risj_oxford, @parkermolloy, @profcarroll, @esqueer_, The Desk, @asharma, @martinsfp, Mediaite, Vanity Fair, Gizmodo, Engadget, Bloomberg, Fortune, Associated Press and The Information, more at Techmeme »
Discussion:
Nilay Patel / The Verge: Welcome to hell, Elon
Alex Wilhelm / TechCrunch: Twitter just keeps getting more expensive
Loree Seitz / The Wrap: 5 Ways Twitter Will Change Under New Owner Elon Musk
Joe Mandese / MediaPost: Does Elon Musk Still Hate Advertising?
David A. Graham / The Atlantic: There May Be No Twitter Comeback for Trump
Ariel Zilber / New York Post: Donald Trump says glad Twitter in ‘sane hands’ with Elon Musk as he touts Truth Social app
Stephanie Stacey / Insider: Right-wing pundits and Russian state media were duped by a fake Trump press release hailing his imminent return to Twitter
Stephanie Condon / ZDNet: Elon Musk promises not to make Twitter a ‘free-for-all hellscape’
@dropkiwifarms: OooO this is interesting. 'if you bring back trump we're immediately stopping our ad campaigns, Elon' It's the only language these people speak - money. Please make this platform safe for all, and not just the trolls. Source: https://www.wsj.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@risj_oxford: 🍑 “About a dozen of GroupM's clients, which own an array of well-known consumer brands, have told the agency to pause all their ads on Twitter if Donald Trump's account is reinstated [by Elon Musk]” https://www.wsj.com/...
Parker Molloy / @parkermolloy: Notice that he doesn't say anything about whether or not he'll tweak the algorithm to create *even more* right-wing bias than there already is (and yes, Twitter does have a right-wing bias: https://www.protocol.com/...), how he'll use people's data, etc. https://twitter.com/...
David Carroll / @profcarroll: “Advertising provided 89% of Twitter's $5.08 billion revenue in 2021. Mr. Musk has said he hates advertising.” https://twitter.com/...
Alejandra Caraballo / @esqueer_: Elon is in for a world of hurt if he abandons content moderation. Advertising accounts for 95% of revenue for Twitter. That's over $4.5 billion/year he'd be burning through in costs if advertisers flee. Subscriptions would never make up the lost revenue. https://www.wsj.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Matthew Keys / The Desk: Elon Musk expected to complete Twitter purchase this week
Amol Sharma / @asharma: If Elon Musk reinstates former President Donald Trump's Twitter account after completing a takeover of the company, several companies plan to suspend ad spending on the platform, a top ad buyer said https://www.wsj.com/...
@martinsfp: Elon Musk tells Twitter employees he *doesn't* plan to cut 75% of jobs (He's still expected to make big cuts) https://www.bloomberg.com/...
Tommy Christopher / Mediaite: Ad Exec Warns Trump Being Reinstated By Elon Musk a ‘Red Line’ For Some Advertisers on Twitter
Lauren Leffer / Gizmodo: Elon Musk Says Twitter Won't Become a ‘Hellscape,’ as Stock Trading Freezes Ahead of Deal
Tristan Bove / Fortune: ‘I did it to try to help humanity, whom I love:’ Elon Musk drops a new statement as his Twitter takeover inches closer and says he won't turn it into a ‘free-for-all hellscape’
Erik Wemple / Washington Post:
A reassessment of The New York Times' apology and James Bennet's firing after Sen. Tom Cotton's op-ed: Bennet was right and Publisher A.G. Sulzberger was wrong — Controversy over an op-ed by Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) consumed the New York Times in June 2020 and claimed the job of then-editorial page editor James Bennet.
Discussion:
@easterbrookg, @jennifersey, @davidfolkenflik, @thomaschattwill, @levinejonathan, @davidharsanyi, @nprinskeep, @heerjeet, @joenbc, @bariweiss, @jeffreyasachs, @toley88, @jeffreyasachs, @jeffjarvis, @nickgillespie, @matthewfoldi, @sethamandel, @jonathanchait, @tomscocca, @coreypein, @davidfrum, @mtracey, @fka_tabs, @tomscocca, @froomkin, @coreypein, @razibkhan, @mattwelch, @sullydish, @anncoulter, @tomscocca, @__seab, @marcbodnick, @garylegum, @tomscocca, @repbrendanboyle, @jbarro, @anncoulter, @isaac_schorr, @semaforben, @jtlol, @nycsouthpaw, @sivavaid, @nancyromm, @lukeoneil47, @__seab, @joeconchatv, @coreypein, @coreypein, @sethamandel, @conor64, @sethamandel, @bariweiss, @rubensteinadam, @kcjohnson9, Mediaite, Fox News and Overtime
Discussion:
Gregg Easterbrook / @easterbrookg: This from @ErikWemple is long overdue - from him, from the entire journalism profession. (Find an editor who's never criticized, and you'll find an editor who's following not leading.) At least some of us did not waver in our support of James Bennet. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Jennifer Sey / @jennifersey: "@ErikWemple ; blog asked ~30 Times staffers whether they still believe their “danger” tweets...Not one of them replied with an on-the-record defense. Such was the depth of conviction." Bennet was right. 2 yrs too late. Still good to see. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
David Folkenflik / @davidfolkenflik: >@ErikWemple : James Bennet was right Not just a you-a culpa but a true me-a culpa here from Wemple https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Thomas Chatterton Williams / @thomaschattwill: “Whereas media outlets typically defend work under attack, the opposite scenario played out over the Cotton op-ed: Top Times officials, according to 3 sources, scrambled to pulverize the essay in order to vindicate objections rolling in from Twitter.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Jon Levine / @levinejonathan: A few *years* late to address this shameful episode https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
David Harsanyi / @davidharsanyi: Brave piece nearly two years after the fact. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Steve Inskeep / @nprinskeep: Here, @ErikWemple says almost every aspect of James Bennet's firing was wrong; says Twitter attacks on a NYT op-ed were as hyperbolic as the op-ed; and even hammers himself: “Our criticism of the Twitter outburst comes 875 days too late.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Jeet Heer / @heerjeet: Wasn't the Times guy fired when he made it clear that he didn't even read the op ed that people were mad at? I mean, that's a “you have one job” situation.
Joe Scarborough / @joenbc: It is good to finally see James Bennet defended by other media outlets. The Times' actions against him were deplorable and set a dangerous precedent in undermining free speech. Bennet is owed an apology. So are loyal readers of the @nytimes. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Bari Weiss / @bariweiss: Of course he was. The correction and the apology is welcome. It's telling that it took two years to be able to say the obvious in The Washington Post without serious threat of career ruin. Easy to list a dozen other subjects about which this is the case. https://twitter.com/...
Jeffrey Sachs / @jeffreyasachs: Quite so. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Tom Ley / @toley88: He was right to run an op-ed he didn't even bother to read, in which a sitting senator called for the national guard to violently crack down on an uprising, during a period when cops were beating people in the street? Weird thing to think, in my opinion! https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Jeffrey Sachs / @jeffreyasachs: @MarcBodnick ... The mission of a newspaper's op-ed page is (or ought to be) to provide readers with a wide swathe of factually-grounded opinions, especially when those opinions belong to powerful people who are in a position to make their desires come true. Obviously there needs to be some...
Jeff Jarvis / @jeffjarvis: Wemple falls in my estimation. And how can anyone read Bennet's Semafor mewling with anything other than contempt and agreement with Sulzberger for firing him? https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Nick Ghoullespie / @nickgillespie: Wow. 'It's also long past time to ask why more people who claim to uphold journalism and free expression — including, um, the Erik Wemple Blog — didn't speak out then in Bennet's defense. It's because we were afraid to.' @ErikWemple HT @conor64 https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Matthew Foldi / @matthewfoldi: Importantly, the point #ARSEN @TomCottonAR was making in the non-controversial op-ed was ALSO right Why did being tough on crime completely break the mainstream media? https://twitter.com/...
Seth Mandel / @sethamandel: One thing though: Wemple & Co. might want to direct some apologies not only to Bennet but to the scapegoats at the Times who were treated like trash and pushed out. ‘Sorry James Bennet’ isn't brave. Let's hear some ‘Sorry Adam Rubenstein.’
Jonathan Chait / @jonathanchait: Conservatives keep talking as if it's still June, 2020. But there are signs of change everywhere. @ErikWemple frankly admits he was afraid to state his concerns about the NYT Tom Cotton debacle at the time, but isn't any more. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Tom Scocca / @tomscocca: Like, this is just nonsense. Cotton was calling for an escalation of the already lawless official armed response to the protests, under false premises, but it would have become lawful? Under the president who would brag about the U.S. Marshals summarily executing a suspect? https://twitter.com/...
David Frum / @davidfrum: .@ErikWemple: “James Bennett was right.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Michael Tracey / @mtracey: Do those of us who stated the obvious at the time get any “credit” https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Rusty Foster / @fka_tabs: Wild time for the Wemple z0ne to set its credibility on fire in defense of James Bennet and the validity of the proposition that the 101st Airborne should start doing domestic law enforcement against Black people. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Tom Scocca / @tomscocca: My original take, exactly one hour after the post went up. Carve it in stone. https://twitter.com/...
@froomkin: You've got to be kidding. @ErikWemple now plays the victim, saying he was “afraid” to support @JBennet at the time. That's pathetic. But his true cowardice is in refusing to say what he was afraid of. For shame. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
@coreypein: > The Twitter chain claiming “danger” to Times staffers suffered from the same journalistic failings leveled at the op-ed. It was an exercise in manipulative hyperbole brilliantly calibrated for immediate impact. Way to bury the lead. Embarrassing. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
@razibkhan: everyone is talking about this piece. 1) there is almost 0% surprising in the piece, so why is it a big deal? 2) probably because wemple admits openly what was always obv: fear is the mind-killer 3) does it matter that they acknowledge what was always known? https://twitter.com/...
Matt Welch / @mattwelch: The politics of forced media apology: “Bennet didn't write the bloated, italicized nostra culpa, according to informed sources — it was a committee product headed by the standards desk, with extensive involvement from Sulzberger himself, sources say.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Andrew Sullivan / @sullydish: Fantastic piece. True in every respect. Of course many of us *did* stand up for James against the mob at the time (and got fired soon after). This was a woke mob hit - designed to send a message to anyone: we run the joint now. And they do. https://twitter.com/...
Ann Coulter / @anncoulter: Re: The scandalous Tom Cotton op-ed that got the Times opinion editor fired because it “puts Black @NYTimes staff in danger.” <<[Asked for] another example of an editor's note apologizing for nonfactual issues. The Times didn't answer that question.>> https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Tom Scocca / @tomscocca: James Bennet as opinion editor never cared about the difference between inviting someone to make a provocative argument and giving them space to just tell lies, but Cotton's false account of what was happening in the protests was materially dangerous beyond the usual bullshit
Blair / @__seab: I don't really care about internal NYT politics, but on June 3rd Cotton called for the troops to be called in. On May 31st NYPD drove SUVs into the crowd I was in. On June 1st, the national guard murdered a man in Kentucky. That's what the danger was. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Marc Bodnick / @marcbodnick: @JeffreyASachs ... The Times should run any proposal from a major US political leader? What if Josh Hawley proposed internment camps for DACA recipients? Is there any limit? I ask because some Rs have become semi-fascist; this isn't hypothetical.
Tom Scocca / @tomscocca: Police all over the country were attacking people, en masse, for exercising their First Amendment rights of speech, assembly, and the press. Officers were deliberately shooting reporters with rubber bullets and tear gas. Cotton was obviously calling to escalate that violence. https://twitter.com/...
US Rep Brendan Boyle / @repbrendanboyle: Fascinating and well worth reading. https://twitter.com/...
Josh Barro / @jbarro: Yes, this is because the “this column puts Black times staff in danger” crowd was full of shit all along. They just didn't like the Times running a column they disagreed with. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
Ann Coulter / @anncoulter: <<Although Bennet said he hadn't read the piece, he was involved in some early decisions about it, including the deletion of a criticism of Hannah-Jones.>> Well, OF COURSE you can't criticize an actual living saint in the NYT! https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Isaac Schorr / @isaac_schorr: James Bennet was right @ErikWemple “asked about 30 NYT staffers” if they still believed the Cotton op-ed put them in danger and not one went on the record. “Such was the depth of conviction behind a central argument in l'affaire Cotton.” Kudos to Wemple. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Ben Smith / @semaforben: Hell of a conclusion to this @ErikWemple column https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
@jtlol: Wemple can't even get through a mea culpa without throwing in some bullshit https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
@nycsouthpaw: Erik Wemple calls the warnings by black staff members of the New York Times that running Tom Cotton's op-ed (the one advocating for Trump to use the military to suppress racial justice protests) would put their safety at risk: “manipulative hyperbole.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
@sivavaid: Now @ErikWemple joins Bennet in minimizing the threat of fascism and pretending it's all in the realm of reasonable debate. Truly shameful. Must be nice to be able to think like this. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Nancy Rommelmann / @nancyromm: I nearly cried with relief upon 1st read, and I commend Wemple for writing it. Still, rereading “Our posture was one of cowardice and midcareer risk management,” I'm astonished. It's like a firefighter saying, well, it was going to be hot in there so... https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Luke / @lukeoneil47: Top 10 dumbest fuck in newspapers. Writer and subject doesn't matter which one I mean. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Blair / @__seab: I have broken my rule of not sharing things on account of being bad, but people were in Clinton Hill banging on doors to pass kids into stranger's homes so the police wouldn't beat them. Some of us didn't forget that.
Joe Concha / @joeconchatv: Oh, I'm certain this media critic objected. https://thehill.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@coreypein: Open invitation for everyone boosting this astoundingly craven Wemple column to suit up and cover the next big protest.
@coreypein: A columnist who says his peers aren't in danger when politicians call for “send[ing] in the troops” to street protests is actually telling you how recently they've done any on-the-ground reporting, and how much they value shoeleather reporting versus op-ed page hackwork.
Seth Mandel / @sethamandel: Respect to Wemple for admitting that much of what drives instant reaction to that stuff is shivering fear of a NHJ mean tweet and no fear whatsoever of the supposed press-squashing fascists on the right that they don't wait two years to criticize.
Conor Friedersdorf / @conor64: Wow. The Washington Post's media critic on why he and others didn't object to unjust treatedment of James Bennet at the NYT: “It's because we were afraid to.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Seth Mandel / @sethamandel: Two years is about the lag time for when it's safe for ‘media critics’ to admit conservatives were right in the moment https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Bari Weiss / @bariweiss: Two years after the fact, but this is a very important correction of the record. Equally important, especially in terms of understanding American journalism of late, is what @ErikWemple admits: he did not defend James Bennet because he was afraid to. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Adam Rubenstein / @rubensteinadam: It took two years, but this is the first mainstream piece to actually report (honestly, factually) on the Tom Cotton Op-Ed. From @ErikWemple https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
KC Johnson / @kcjohnson9: “The Erik Wemple Blog has asked about 30 Times staffers whether they still believe their ‘danger’ tweets and whether there was any merit in Bennet's retort. Not one of them replied with an on-the-record defense.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Kipp Jones / Mediaite: WaPo Media Critic Explains Why Paper Didn't Defend Fired NYT Editor After Tom Cotton Op-Ed Furor: ‘We Were Afraid’
Fox News: Our ‘cowardice’ prevented us from defending James Bennet amid NYT's Tom Cotton op-ed uproar: WaPo media critic
Jim Swift / Overtime: These 4 Ballot Initiatives Might Tell the Future
Ashley King / Digital Music News:
Music streaming service LiveOne and its subsidiary Slacker say a ruling ordering them to pay SoundExchange ~$10M in royalties could cause financial ruin — Is Slacker headed for bankruptcy? The company says SoundExchange's $10 million judgment could destroy them.
Defector:
Defector reports $3.8M in annual revenue, up from $3.2M in 2021, $3.7M in expenses, up from $3M in 2021, and 38K subscribers, who generated 95% of its revenue — Purpose of this report — Defector continues to have no outside investors and no intention of raising outside capital.
Discussion:
Nieman Lab, Adweek, Media Voices, @film_girl, @defectormedia, @jayrosen_nyu, @mattdpearce, @madbastardsall, @aznfusion, @sarahscire, @mckinneykelsey, @ahazlett, @taylorkatebrown, @theisen95, @lyzl, @defectormedia, @defectormedia, @defectormedia, @defectormedia, @drewmagary, @scott_tobias, @markstenberg3, @mckinneykelsey and @adweek
Discussion:
Media Voices: Friday 28th October: Defector is profitable in Y2, with almost every dollar coming from readers
Chriscreama Warren / @film_girl: Proud to be an Accomplice for the third year running. Here's to many more! https://twitter.com/...
@defectormedia: We've gotten helpful feedback by reaching out to people who have cancelled their subscriptions, and also this comment from our own Ray Ratto. https://defector.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Jay Rosen / @jayrosen_nyu: Defector is an employee-owned sports and culture site founded by former Deadspin staffers. Nearly every dollar comes from readers. In their second year, they are profitable. https://www.niemanlab.org/...
Matt Pearce / @mattdpearce: I'm really happy for what my @DefectorMedia friends have built, and I appreciate their transparency, which shows that other, more journalist-friendly business models are possible. https://twitter.com/...
Chris O'Lantern Thompson / @madbastardsall: while this is true, the email in question was only approximately one percent too creepy. we will happily send out emails that are 99 percent as creepy as this one https://www.niemanlab.org/...
Sabrina Imbler / @aznfusion: happy Defector Two Year Annual Report Day to all who celebrate! I am very proud to work here 😤 https://defector.com/...
Sarah Scire / @sarahscire: turns out I was not the only one briefly alarmed by the @ToLey88 “I see what you're up to” email https://www.niemanlab.org/...
Kelsey Mckinney / @mckinneykelsey: You can see that in the year two annual report, which is out today. We are taking (calculated!) risks that no other media company is making despite having LESS money and LESS of a safety net. And people WANT to pay for that because the product is good. https://defector.com/...
Alex Hazlett / @ahazlett: Every managementy person in media should be reading @DefectorMedia's annual report “Good blogs are good for business, whether that's keeping current subscribers happy or attracting new readers.” https://defector.com/...
Taylor Kate Brown / @taylorkatebrown: I'm not a regular reader of @DefectorMedia but I do listen to @NormalGossip and I do love their absolutely-not-at-all-mandated annual report, including this particular email note: https://defector.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Lauren Theisen / @theisen95: The coolest part of this report is that, to make up for not raising prices, we offered to send David Roth and a cardboard Roth to somebody's house, and it worked! Over 1300 of you have entered the contest. https://defector.com/...
Lyz Lenz / @lyzl: Media companies are increasingly less willing to take risks. And podcasts are focusing on celebs. Defector took a chance, believed in the voice and vision and let an employee run with it. And it's a success. https://twitter.com/...
@defectormedia: Overall, our goals for Year 3 are 1) Making enough money to keep making Defector what we want it to be; and 2) Reaching more people with our work. We remain very proud of this business we've built and the community around it. https://defector.com/...
@defectormedia: Good blogs continue to be our best marketing tool. We increased our on-the-ground reporting this year and commissioned freelance work from over 50 writers and a dozen artists. https://defector.com/...
@defectormedia: An important part of our growth is the hit podcast Normal Gossip, which averages 250,000 streams per episode and brought in ~2,500 gross subscriptions from its ‘Friend’ and ‘Friend-of-a-Friend’ tiers. https://defector.com/...
@defectormedia: Defector recognized $3.8 mm in revenue this year, 95 percent of which came from subscriptions. We reached a high water mark of 41k net active subscribers in early September 2022. https://defector.com/...
Drew Magary / @drewmagary: Unlike SOME companies (Meta), Defector Media is not only growing, but doing so by offering you products that aren't complete dogshit. Read all about our financials here, in our second annual report. https://defector.com/...
Scott Tobias / @scott_tobias: The mere existence of this @DefectorMedia annual report is reason to support them, beyond its continued first-rate writing. An independent, subscription-driven operation is ideal for readers and journalists alike IMO: https://defector.com/...
Mark Stenberg / @markstenberg3: New: The hit podcast Normal Gossip, which launched a subscription product in May, has generated 2,500 subscribers for Defector Media. The monetization strategy offers a novel case study for publishers looking to capitalize on audio products. For @Adweek: https://www.adweek.com/...
Kelsey Mckinney / @mckinneykelsey: I'm thrilled that Normal Gossip has been able to bring in money for @DefectorMedia, and I also want to note that this was a risk no other podcast or media company would consider. (Now, of course, they want it.) Defector bet on it. We bet on it. https://www.adweek.com/...
Daniel Finn / The Wire:
Q&A with Tom Mills, the author of The BBC: Myth of a Public Service, on the BBC's start in 1922, government relationships, rethinking the license fee, and more — No broadcaster in the world today can rival the cultural prestige of the UK's British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC).
David Gutman / The Seattle Times:
A Washington judge fines Meta $24.66M, the maximum possible amount, after finding the company intentionally violated campaign finance disclosure laws 822 times — Meta, Facebook's parent company, was fined nearly $25 million Wednesday for intentionally and repeatedly violating Washington's campaign finance laws.
Discussion:
Washington State, Associated Press, The Hill, @katieharbath, @jvagle, @evelyndouek, Horrific/Terrific, @agowa, CNET, MediaPost and Gizmodo
Discussion:
Washington State: Judge grants AG Ferguson's request for maximum $24.6M penalty against Facebook parent Meta
Associated Press: Facebook's parent is fined nearly $25M for violating a campaign finance disclosure law
Katie Harbath / @katieharbath: So much to unpack here, but this issue in WA state could be a great microcosm of what will happen more as regulators and judges try to hold tech accountable ... but don't always fully understand how the tech works. https://twitter.com/...
Jeffrey Vagle / @jvagle: Also why large platforms may be so keen on federal preemption generally. https://twitter.com/...
Evelyn Douek / @evelyndouek: Who needs a platform specific transparency law when you have good old-fashioned political ad transparency laws I guess! https://twitter.com/...
Martin Pengelly / The Guardian:
More than 500 authors and others working in publishing sign an open letter to Penguin Random House protesting Amy Coney Barrett's $2M book deal — More than 250 literary figures rail against acquisition by Penguin Random House of book by conservative US supreme court justice
Discussion:
The Wrap, Mediaite, @samthielman, @katzonearth, @nicoperrino, @nicoperrino, @samthielman, @josephoneillx, @heckelfonic, @nicoperrino, @penamerica and @xor
Discussion:
Benjamin Lindsay / The Wrap: Penguin Random House Staffers, Others Call for Canceling of Amy Coney Barrett Memoir
Zachary Leeman / Mediaite: Penguin Employees and Others Sign Open Letter Demanding Publisher Spike Amy Coney Barrett Memoir Over Abortion Vote
Jonathan M. Katz / @katzonearth: Excited to learn that every time a publisher doesn't give me a $2 million advance it's basically the equivalent of the Nazis burning books https://twitter.com/...
Nico Perrino / @nicoperrino: Efforts to ban books are on the rise. One would hope that those who have the most to lose from such censorship would be opposed to it. Instead, they want a publisher to pull a planned book authored by Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett.
Nico Perrino / @nicoperrino: Like all speech codes, this new “duty of care” rule would be selectively enforced, often with political biases, and will depend for its survival on double standards. For example, they do not call on Penguin to stop publishing Mein Kampf: https://www.penguin.co.uk/...
@samthielman: The idea that book publishers must support completely unrestricted speech is not an adult position https://twitter.com/...
Joseph O'Neill / @josephoneillx: Judges should not use their office to launch a lucrative new career. https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Anwen Crawford / @heckelfonic: Not saying I predicted this; I am saying that I'm right. See also: PRH choosing to pay that ghoul Amy Coney Barrett $2mil for her book: https://www.theguardian.com/ ... The money exists. What publishers spend it on is a political choice. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Nico Perrino / @nicoperrino: 250 members of the literary world, including many who work in the book publishing industry, signed an open letter to @penguinrandom calling for ... book banning? https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Ashley Carman / Bloomberg:
Spotify's contracts show podcasters who use SPAN, its programmatic ad marketplace, split revenue 50/50 and Spotify doesn't guarantee competitive ads won't run — Hey y'all. The sun finally came out in New York today. It's glorious, and it's Thursday. As always, replying to this email reaches an unmonitored inbox.
Discussion:
Kaya Yurieff / The Information:
Twitter confirms the company shut down its Ticketed Spaces test indefinitely before Elon Musk's takeover — Before Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, the company paused paid tickets to its live audio feature Spaces, the social network confirmed. “We've paused the Ticketed Spaces test indefinitely …
Benjamin Mullin / New York Times:
In an email, Chris Licht told staff that CNN will stop buying documentary films and original TV series and instead use long-form content produced internally — Acquired and commissioned documentary movies and TV shows like ‘Navalny’ and ‘Stanley Tucci: Searching for Italy’ are going away.
Discussion:
Brian Steinberg / Variety: CNN to Pull Back on Original Series, Films