Top News:
New York Times:
A court filing in the Dominion-Fox lawsuit shows more texts and emails from hosts and executives privately expressing disbelief about stolen US election claims — The comments, by Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity and others, were released as part of a defamation suit against Fox News by Dominion Voter Systems.
Discussion:
Superior Court of the State of Delaware, @erikwemple, Wall Street Journal, Mediaite, @willsommer, @anniegrayercnn, The Daily Beast, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, Washington Post, CNN, @oliverdarcy, @jonkarl, Media Matters for America, Puck, The Atlantic, Reason, @davidaxelrod, @kbandersen, Wonkette, @pbump@journa.host, Newser, @pbump@journa.host, TVNewser, @joelkatz, MediaPost, Slate, @jocelynbenson, @johnpavlovitz, @oliverdarcy, Vanity Fair, Rolling Stone, @binarybits, @maximlott, Tierney's Real News, @ememess, New York Magazine, Politico, Media Nation, @ariehkovler, The Hill, @harrylitman, @hasanthehun, @ryanjreilly, @nicoleperlroth, @gtconway3dg, @billpascrell, @oliverdarcy, Columbia Journalism Review, @cherijacobus, @normeisen, @oliverdarcy, @oliverdarcy, @jimlaporta, @beyondreasdoubt, @nikkimcr, @bubbaprog, @libcasey, @andylevy, @orinkerr, @petestrzok, @erikwemple, @rmtiede, @jonfavs, @erikwemple, @davidfrum, @erikwemple, The Guardian, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @gtconway3d, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @betsy_klein, @erikwemple, @erikwemple, @kevinmkruse, @radiofreetom, @davidfolkenflik, @existentialfish, @existentialfish, @existentialfish, @existentialfish, @badfoxgraphics, @existentialfish, @existentialfish, @badfoxgraphics, @existentialfish, @existentialfish, @rschooley, @elizlanders, Boing Boing, @svdate, @gtconway3d, @jwpetersnyt, The Daily Beast, Letters from an American, Insider, @SteveBellovin@mastodon … and @Teri_Kanefield@law …
Discussion:
Superior Court of the State of Delaware: Dominion Voting Systems v. Fox News Network, Fox Corp and Fox Broadcasting
@erikwemple: By filing its suit and plowing through discovery, Dominion has produced perhaps the most piercing look at the internal goings-on at Fox News in its quarter-century history.
Wall Street Journal: Fox News Hosts, Executives Raised Concerns About 2020 Election-Fraud Claims Made on the Air, Filing Shows
Alex Griffing / Mediaite: Fox Blocked Trump from Going on Air During Capitol Attack, Exec Testified: ‘Would Be Irresponsible to Put Him On’
Will Sommer / @willsommer: This filing in the Dominion lawsuit against Fox News is one of the most remarkable documents I've ever seen. Filled with private texts between Fox stars like Hannity and Carlson, plus Murdoch, all admitting they knew Fox's stolen election claims were lies. https://int.nyt.com/...
Annie Grayer / @anniegrayercnn: Buried in the Dominion filing: Donald Trump dialed into Lou Dobbs' show on 1/6 trying to get on air but Fox would not let him. 1/6 committee didn't know Trump had made this call, according to a source familiar with the panel's work. https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: More: After a Fox News staffer correctly fact-checked stuff that was coming out of the network's opinion side, all hell broke loose among the prime-timers. Stunning: https://twitter.com/...
@erikwemple: Huge day in the Dominion Voting Systems v. Fox News defamation case, with both sides filing summary-judgment motions. Dominion's version is a nearly 200-page document bursting with text messages from network talent in the tense days following the 2020 presidential election. 1/
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Have a look at this collection of Fox quotes from November 2020, as Sidney Powell and others were spinning their case that the presidential election was stolen. https://twitter.com/...
Annie Grayer / CNN: Fox News executives refused to let Trump on-air when he called in during January 6 attack, Dominion says
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: Fox's top stars wanted @JacquiHeinrich fired for fact-checking a tweet about election lies. Carlson told Hannity: “Please get her fired. Seriously ... what the fuck?” https://twitter.com/...
Jonathan Karl / @jonkarl: Tucker Carlson's reaction to a Fox News reporter telling the truth: “Please get her fired,” Mr. Carlson said. He added: “It needs to stop immediately, like tonight. It's measurably hurting the company. The stock price is down. Not a joke.” https://www.nytimes.com/...
Media Matters for America: They knew it was a lie: The behind-the-scenes happenings at Fox while the network pushed false claims about Dominion
Dylan Byers / Puck: Fox Fallout & Lemon's Lumps
Tom Nichols / The Atlantic: The Real Elitists Are at Fox News
Jacob Sullum / Reason: Rupert Murdoch Called Trump's Stolen-Election Fantasy ‘Really Crazy Stuff.’ Fox News Promoted It Anyway.
David Axelrod / @davidaxelrod: Worse than believing a heinous and destructive lie is KNOWING it's a lie and still giving it oxygen for competitive reasons. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Kurt Andersen / @kbandersen: Yes. Read it. Wow. 100 smoking guns. Vast evidence of @FoxNews talent & executives knowingly spreading the Big Lie. Their panic about viewer reaction when Fox occasionally aired truth—as one executive said: “It's remarkable how weak ratings make good journalists do bad things.” https://twitter.com/...
Doktor Zoom / Wonkette: Boy, Those Fox News Texts, I Don't Know
Philip Bump / @pbump@journa.host: Fox let Trump lie with abandon for years, building a loyal Trump audience. Then it made that bad call on Arizona that pissed off viewers. Then Newsmax had space to eat away at its audience. …
Rob Quinn / Newser: In Private, Fox Stars Mocked Election Fraud Claims
Philip Bump / @pbump@journa.host: The Dominion filing against Fox is a bombshell, but the important thing it elevates is less the network's embrace of fraud claims but, instead, a pattern of dishonesty and mistakes that led Fox to do so. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
Mark Mwachiro / TVNewser: Latest Court Filings From Dominion Show Fox News Works Hard to Protect Its Brand
@joelkatz: Dominion has the strongest defamation case I've ever seen against Fox News. This could easily result in a 9 figure award. (Relax, that's like 5% of Fox News.) https://twitter.com/...
Karlene Lukovitz / MediaPost: Dominion Filing Reveals Fox Players' Disbelief Of Voter Fraud Claims
Jeremy Stahl / Slate: Tucker Carlson's Dominion Text Messages Are a Thing of Beauty
Jocelyn Benson / @jocelynbenson: So lets be real: a *lot* of powerful voices who have spread & amplified election misinformation these last few years have knowingly & intentionally done so. The facts & truth about the security & accuracy of elections are there for all who want to see it. https://www.cnn.com/...
John Pavlovitz / @johnpavlovitz: The election was not stolen, only millions of people's critical thinking abilities. https://www.cnn.com/...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: The WSJ has now (finally) published a story on the Dominion filing. https://www.wsj.com/...
Charlotte Klein / Vanity Fair: “Our Viewers...Believe It”: What Fox News Execs and Stars Were Really Thinking While the Network Boosted Donald Trump's Election Lies
Ryan Bort / Rolling Stone: Tucker Carlson Pushes Election Fraud B.S. Same Night Filing Reveals He Knows It's B.S.
Timothy B. Lee / @binarybits: I don't agree with the “typical NYT” part but this does seem like a good point. https://twitter.com/...
Maxim Lott / @maximlott: Dishonest “reporting” by @nytimes @jwpetersNYT @katie_robertson. Cites @TuckerCarlson texts calling a Trump lawyer a liar ... and acts as if they show he was happy to mislead audience But Carlson called out Trump's lawyer ON AIR at the time! https://www.youtube.com/... Typical NYT https://twitter.com/...
Michael Marshall Smith / @ememess: People died because of deliberate lies from Fox. Faith in democratic elections has been crucially undermined. They enabled and promoted the cause of domestic terrorism. The consequences for this should go well beyond the Dominion lawsuit. https://www.cnn.com/...
Jonathan Chait / New York Magazine: Tucker Carlson Tried to Get Fox News Reporter Fired for Fact-Checking Trump
Rachael Bade / Politico: Fox's 2020 split screen revealed
Dan Kennedy / Media Nation: Why relevations that Fox stars knew Trump was lying may boost Dominion's libel suit
Arieh Kovler / @ariehkovler: Read this thread or, better, the whole filing. It's extraordinary. Fox's top stars all colluded to lie about the election because they were worried their business would suffer if they didn't. https://twitter.com/...
Dominick Mastrangelo / The Hill: Fox News hosts, execs privately blasted Trump election fraud claims shared on network, court documents show
Harry Litman / @harrylitman: Documents showing Fox stars, and Murdoch, knew the Big Lie was just that. eg Carlson to Ingraham: “Sidney Powell is lying by the way. I caught her. It's insane.” Will be very strong evidence in defamation suits. https://www.nytimes.com/...
@hasanthehun: real demon shit here but as is the case w many of these lawsuits surrounding fox news, or other rw figures like alex jones, their fans will never realize they're being lied to all the time by people who openly admit they're lying in the court documents. https://twitter.com/...
Ryan J. Reilly / @ryanjreilly: “The afternoon of January 6, after the Capitol came under attack, then President Trump dialed into Lou Dobbs show attempting to get on air. But Fox executives vetoed that decision.” https://twitter.com/...
Nicole Perlroth / @nicoleperlroth: Not a lawyer but it certainly looks like Dominion has the goods in its $1.6B lawsuit against Fox. Fox Stars Privately Expressed Disbelief About Trump's Election Fraud Claims - The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/...
@gtconway3dg: I'm reminded that as part of Sidney Powell's defense, her lawyer argued in March 2021 that “no reasonable person would conclude that the statements were truly statements of fact.” https://twitter.com/...
Bill Pascrell, Jr. / @billpascrell: The republican party's top propaganda outlet knew it was spreading election lies and kept doing it to continue to radicalizing millions. Every American should read these documents. https://twitter.com/...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: A person with direct knowledge of the matter tells me that Heinrich was blindsided reading the details in the legal filing tonight and was not aware of the efforts by top hosts behind the scenes to get her fired.
Cheri Jacobus / @cherijacobus: “It's remarkable how weak ratings make... good journalists do bad things,” Bill Sammon, at the time the network's Washington Managing Editor, privately wrote on Dec. 2, 2020." Off the air, Fox News stars blasted the election fraud claims they peddled https://www.npr.org/...
Norm Eisen / @normeisen: Dominion's brief tearing the facade off of Fox News is a defining document of the era of election denial, together with the 1/6 Committee report—and the coming Georgia indictment of Trump. “Fox knew."https://int.nyt.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: This is what Tucker Carlson said at the top of his show TONIGHT. https://twitter.com/...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: It's almost like Tucker Carlson is a different guy behind the scenes than he is in front of the camera. https://twitter.com/...
Jim LaPorta / @jimlaporta: .@TuckerCarlson of @FoxNews wanted @JacquiHeinrich of @FoxNews fired for *checks notes* doing her job at @FoxNews by fact checking a claim made by the President https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@beyondreasdoubt: You know the joke “discovery will be lit 🔥” well here it is irl ... this thread man https://twitter.com/...
@nikkimcr: Lest we forget that Fox fired Chris Stirewalt for not caving to the election conjecture being spun by his on-air colleagues https://twitter.com/...
Timothy Burke / @bubbaprog: There has perhaps never been a greater illustration of what “knowledge that it was false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not” than every person who works at Fox after the 2020 election https://twitter.com/...
Libby Casey / @libcasey: “Mind-blowingly nuts,” “totally off the rails” and “completely bs.” -Fox News stars, producers & execs comments on Trump's false election claims...in private. Even as they peddled the lies on TV. By @davidfolkenflik @NPR https://www.npr.org/...
Andy / @andylevy: gotta be a rough night for the handful of people left at fnc who are capable of feeling embarrassment or shame https://twitter.com/...
Orin Kerr / @orinkerr: This is quite a legal brief. It was filed today in Delaware state court by Dominion Voting Sytems in its defamation lawsuit against Fox News. (via @nytimes) https://int.nyt.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Pete Strzok / @petestrzok: Bill Barr and Jeff Jensen did. Btw, where's the long-rumored DOJ OPR report looking into all that? Dead and forgotten in the main Justice sub basement? https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: One thing that leaps out of the document is just how panicked were network officials about the viewers' disenchantment with the network's very early call of Arizona for Biden. It appears the whole place was in a state of revolt: https://twitter.com/...
Jon Favreau / @jonfavs: Fox News in a nutshell: Georgetown Populist Tucker Carlson is enraged that a colleague's truthful reporting is hurting his company's stock price. https://twitter.com/...
@erikwemple: The minutiae disclosed in the Dominion filing are scandalous: They show just how incompatible is the hosts' candid chatter with the product they put on the airwaves — and the reason for that gulf is ratings. Period.
David Frum / @davidfrum: Fox News is going to need to mint a quadrillion dollar platinum coin of its own to pay the libel judgment it will owe to Dominion Voting Systems https://twitter.com/...
@erikwemple: The argument from Dominion — bolstered by correspondence among the network's top people — is that Fox News knew all too well that the stolen-election claims were a lie, yet they plowed ahead with programming indicating the opposite. /3
The Guardian: Carlson and Hannity among Fox hosts who didn't believe election fraud claims - court filings
@erikwemple: In its own summary judgment brief filed today, Fox News argued that: *President Trump's campaign to overturn the 2020 election was newsworthy; *The statements in question were not “actionable defamation”; *Fox News hosts were covering these allegations, not advocating them;
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: A big part of the Fox News defense is the claim that Dominion's damages claim of $1.6 billion is a huge crock. Here's an important passage from the Fox News document: https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: What's more, Fox News claims that the record doesn't establish “actual malice” on part of the Fox News hosts. That means that they either knew the claims were false or proceeded with reckless disregard. To buttress this line of defense, Fox News argues: https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: More Fox News defense arguments: *The Fox News filing details moments in the coverage when hosts make statements clarifying that the Powell-Giuliani-Trump allegations are just that: allegations; Here's a critical passage explaining this defense: https://twitter.com/...
George Conway / @gtconway3d: It sure looks like the applicable First Amendment standard for liability will be met .... https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Some additional defense from a Fox News spokesperson: https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Fox News today issued a statement regarding the Dominion filing: https://twitter.com/...
Betsy Klein / @betsy_klein: “Mr. Carlson continued, ‘Our viewers are good people and they believe it,’ he added, making clear that he did not.” https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: Fox News wiggled out of a defamation suit by arguing people shouldn't take the programming seriously (specifically, Tucker Carlson's show). Perhaps to fend off that defense, the Dominion filing goes into detail to show that the network's people see themselves as journalists: https://twitter.com/...
Erik Wemple / @erikwemple: More material in which Fox News people affirm they're in the news biz: https://twitter.com/...
Kevin M. Kruse / @kevinmkruse: Do Bond villains make an appearance in the Fox News texts? Yes, they do. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Tom Nichols / @radiofreetom: It's almost like they are horrendous elitists who only admitted the truth to each other, while letting the rubes lap up the nutty conspiracy theories for ratings. https://twitter.com/...
David Folkenflik / @davidfolkenflik: For Fox News, calling Arizona for Biden in 20202 caused “brand damage” and internal crisis. Carlson, Hannity & top execs dismissed election fraud claims as baseless - but privately denounced colleagues who said so publicly, including Cavuto. My story: https://www.npr.org/...
@existentialfish: Fox exec on Newsmax: “They're not a news organization....[W]e have to follow journalistic rules...they do not have to and they simply do not.” https://twitter.com/...
@existentialfish: On January 5, 2021, Rupert Murdoch suggested all Fox primetime hosts issue a statement that the election was over and Biden won. https://twitter.com/...
@existentialfish: “as early as November 5, Fox's Chief Political Correspondent Bret Baier stated privately ‘There is NO evidence of fraud. None.’” https://twitter.com/...
Bad Fox Graphics / @badfoxgraphics: 2/ “Please get her fired. Seriously....what the fuck?” -@TuckerCarlson to @seanhannity after @JacquiHeinrich fact-checked a Trump tweet reporting there is no evidence that Dominion voting machines deleted, lost, or changed votes Heinrich deleted her fact check by morning. https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@existentialfish: Fox execs were unhappy when a Fox reporter fact checked Giuliani and Sidney Powell's insane press conference, even calling the reporter to tell her that. Meanwhile, Ingraham and Tucker were calling her crazy. https://twitter.com/...
@existentialfish: The list of Fox execs who participated in relevant meetings includes both Rupert Murdoch and Lachlan Murdoch https://twitter.com/...
Bad Fox Graphics / @badfoxgraphics: “We need to fact check” -@BretBaier 🙄 Motion for summary judgment against @FoxNews has been filed, and Dominion has the goods. 🧵 https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
@existentialfish: Tucker Carlson said that a Fox reporter should be fired for fact-checking one of Trump's tweets on Dominion. Fox exec Suzanne Scott said the reporter “has serious nerve doing this” https://twitter.com/...
@existentialfish: Tucker Carlson says that he tried to get the Trump White House to disavow Sidney Powell https://twitter.com/...
Schooley / @rschooley: Can the whole Fox prime time line up suddenly go on a long planned vacation I wonder. https://twitter.com/...
Elizabeth Landers / @elizlanders: If you have been following the lies surrounding the 2020 election, this latest filing in the defamation suit between Dominion Voting Systems and Fox News is... stunning. 1 example: Fox News hosts talking about Sidney Powell, calling her a “complete nut” https://int.nyt.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Mark Frauenfelder / Boing Boing: In private text, Tucker Carlson complains about a “demonic” Donald Trump
@svdate: This is amazing. Fox's top hosts, executives all knew that the lunatic claims about rigged voting machines were false and broadcast them anyway because ratings. That would be malice. https://www.nytimes.com/... https://www.nytimes.com/... https://twitter.com/...
George Conway / @gtconway3d: “'Sidney Powell is lying by the way. I caught her. It's insane,' Mr. Carlson wrote to Ms. Ingraham on Nov. 18, 2020. “Ms. Ingraham responded: ‘Sidney is a complete nut. No one will work with her. Ditto with Rudy.’ “Mr. Carlson continued, 'Our viewers are good people and they... https://twitter.com/...
Jeremy W. Peters / @jwpetersnyt: Tucker Carlson, to Laura Ingraham: “Sidney Powell is lying by the way. I caught her. It's insane.” Ingraham: “Sidney is a complete nut. No one will work with her. Ditto with Rudy.” That wasn't exactly what they were saying on the air. https://www.nytimes.com/...
Zachary Petrizzo / The Daily Beast: Fox News Fretted Over Mike Lindell, So They Allegedly Sent Him a ‘Gift’ He Never Got
Heather Cox Richardson / Letters from an American: A legal filing today in the case of Dominion Voting Systems against the Fox News Corporation provides …
Insider: Sidney Powell cited woman who claimed to be headless, time-traveling entity in email pushing election conspiracy theories
Steve Bellovin / @SteveBellovin@mastodon.lawprofs.org: When I read https://mastodon.social/... my first thought was “this sounds like actual malice”. Even ChatGPT seems to understand the concept...
RELATED:
Oliver Darcy / CNN:
Text messages and emails in the Dominion-Fox suit show that Fox News hosts and executives feared losing audience to Newsmax, which embraced election denialism — New York CNN — — Fox News has been exposed like never before. — A trove of newly-released text messages and emails …
Discussion:
The Atlantic, Washington Post, NPR, New York Times, @oliverdarcy, Variety, @deggans, @jysexton, @janeotn, Media Matters for America, @kazweida, @chasten, The Guardian, @senwhitehouse, @nxthompson, Insider, Associated Press, Mediaite, New York Daily News, @brentnyt, @oliverdarcy, @kimmasters, @scottlinnen, @evanmcmurry, @rschooley, @brianros1, @brianstelter and Deadline
Discussion:
Brian Stelter / The Atlantic: I Never Truly Understood Fox News Until Now
David Folkenflik / NPR: Off the air, Fox News stars blasted the election fraud claims they peddled
Michelle Goldberg / New York Times: What Fox News Says When You're Not Listening
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: One big takeaway from the Dominion bombshell filing: Fox News is terrified of its own audience. https://www.cnn.com/...
Gene Maddaus / Variety: Fox News Lied to Viewers to Keep Them From Fleeing, According to Dominion Suit
@deggans: Another argument Fox News Channel is a political operation disguised as a cable newschannel: material from the Dominion voting systems lawsuit — in which FNC's top anchors deride the election conspiracy theories they would push on air: https://www.npr.org/...
Jared Yates Sexton / @jysexton: GOP politics has always been a small group of elites with cosmopolitan traits and backgrounds radicalizing a base using racist, sexist, and xenophobic fearmongering. Power switched away from the traditional groups and to the base. And they hate it. https://twitter.com/...
@janeotn: “In the days after Biden won the election, while Trump shouted “Stop the Steal,” the most powerful people at Fox News were not concerned about the health of U.S. democracy. They were concerned about Fox's brand and their own bottom line.” Shut down Fox. https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Media Matters for America: Fox News lied about Dominion and the 2020 election to compete with far-right Newsmax
Kaz Weida / @kazweida: This is spot on. “...despite privately acknowledging the realiity of the situation, the network allowed the lies on air, in large part because executives & hosts were terrified that telling its sizable audience the truth would prompt them to tune out.” https://www.cnn.com/...
Chasten Buttigieg / @chasten: Misinformation is a threat to democracy, but unfortunately selling misinformation is more important to the people who profit from it. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
The Guardian: Fox News hosts thought Trump's election fraud claims were ‘total BS’, court filings show
Sheldon Whitehouse / @senwhitehouse: An honest courtroom is a beautiful thing. Litigation brought out the truths that FOX mouthpieces shared with each other while busily selling the lies on the air. https://www.washingtonpost.com/ ...
@nxthompson: “Inside Fox, the prime-time stars and senior executives raged against the network's reporters not because they doubted that Biden had won, but because the truth was too disturbing to the audience that had made them rich.” @brianstelter https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Sonam Sheth / Insider: Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham privately called Rudy Giuliani ‘an insane person’ and an ‘idiot’
Aidan McLaughlin / Mediaite: 6 Bombshell Revelations From Trove of New Evidence in Fox News Defamation Suit
Dave Goldiner / New York Daily News: Fox News hosts Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity privately trashed ‘insane’ Trump election lies while promoting them to viewers: Dominion lawsuit
Brent Staples / @brentnyt: Call it by its rightful name https://www.cnn.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Oliver Darcy / @oliverdarcy: “Other sources at Fox told me to think of it not as a network per se, but as a profit machine. They feared doing anything that would disrupt the machine.” https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Scott Linnen / @scottlinnen: The people who brought us Charlottesville, Pittsburgh, El Paso, Capitol Hill, Buffalo, and Colorado Springs are terrified of the Frankenstein monster they've created. https://twitter.com/...
Evan McMurry / @evanmcmurry: Great seeing @brianstelter in @TheAtlantic: “The consensus view both inside and outside the network was that Fox's acknowledgment of reality—and specifically its early projection that Biden had won Arizona—had turned the audience against the network.” https://www.theatlantic.com/ ...
Brian Rosenwald / @brianros1: This goes for all of conservative media. They are worried about alienating the audience — especially over the last 15 years or so as competition has increased & they know their audience will get the most crazy hard right stuff whether they embrace it or not. https://twitter.com/...
The Daily Beast:
Memo: The New York Times Executive Editor Joe Kahn defends the outlet's trans coverage and warns staff and contributors not to campaign or attack colleagues — “We do not welcome, and will not tolerate, participation by Times journalists” in protests over the paper's coverage of trans issues, its executive editor wrote.
Discussion:
@maxwelltani, The Guardian, @madelesque, @jeremylittau, @melissagira, @ggreeneva, PRWeek, @willmcavoyacn, @froomkin, @ijbailey, @emilycrockett, @guardianus, Advocate, @msignorile, New Statesman, NBC News, @erratarob, @jessespector, @redlianak, @nberlat, Newser, @madelesque, @jonathanchait, @jonathanchait, @cohnrussell, @megan_nicolett, @lukeoneil47, @beijingpalmer, @beijingpalmer, @lukeoneil47, @beijingpalmer, @whstancil, @whstancil, @hamiltonnolan, @whstancil, @samthielman, @byjudedoyle, @woahitsjuanito, @femme_thoughts, @samthielman, @lukeoneil47, @toley88, @dick_nixon, @gaywonk, @transscribe, @feliciasonmez, @oneunderscore__, @dellcam, @elivalley, @karlbode, @dellcam, @louispeitzman, @tzimmer_history …, @parkermolloy@masto.ai, New York Post, Los Angeles Times, Reason and @rain@hachyderm.io
Discussion:
Max Tani / @maxwelltani: Memo from Joe Kahn to NYT staff responding to yesterday's letter re: trans coverage. Times leadership says the paper “will not tolerate, participation by Times journalists in protests organized by advocacy groups or attacks on colleagues on social media and other public forums.” https://twitter.com/...
Gloria Oladipo / The Guardian: Nearly 1,000 contributors protest New York Times' coverage of trans people
Madeline Leung Coleman / @madelesque: I am deeply disappointed and disgusted that my employer @nymag published this in response to the open letters to NYT. Distorting, wrongheaded, shortsighted, un-fact-checked. And by the way, check out this line! https://twitter.com/...
Jeremy Littau / @jeremylittau: Please don't take sides with advocacy groups because it makes you not neutral, says the publication that ran a piece with the headline “In Defense of J.K. Rowling.” https://twitter.com/...
Melissa Gira Grant / @melissagira: “It's so easy for an editor to write off somebody they construe as partial, saying, ‘This person is essentially akin to a disgruntled source or an activist,’ and that's not the kind of person The New York Times listens to,' Livingstone said.” https://www.nbcnews.com/...
Greg Greene / @ggreeneva: I mean, as GLAAD notes, the Times keeps conflating two groups: concerned journalists, and an outside activist group. If the Times has proof that the former is speaking _for_ the latter, it should report that out. Otherwise that assertion looks gratuitous and gross. https://twitter.com/...
Jess Ruderman / PRWeek: New York Times responds to criticism of transgender coverage
Will McAvoy / @willmcavoyacn: Remember when the New York Times got rid of their public editor? https://twitter.com/...
@froomkin: This is a fantastic essay by @ijbailey. Here's the first paragraph: https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Emily Crockett / @emilycrockett: They were super sneaky in that perfectly NYT way of being not *technically* inaccurate, but absolutely giving the wrong impression. “A letter” refers to the GLAAD one. Then journos “joined the effort.” An “effort” could consist of multiple letters to the same end! 🙄 https://twitter.com/...
@guardianus: Nearly 1,000 contributors protest New York Times' coverage of trans people https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Michelangelo Signorile / @msignorile: Wow, they got really angry upstairs. Keep hitting them harder. New York Times Blasts Staffers Who Condemned Paper's Trans Coverage https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ... via @thedailybeast
Jo Yurcaba / NBC News: N.Y. Times contributors and LGBTQ advocates send open letters criticizing paper's trans coverage
@erratarob: Disagreement with Rowling is legitimate. Sure, I hate the cancel culture. But the above “Defense” implies there's no good reason to disagree with Rowling. There are lots of good reasons, she's a tiny bit transphobic. https://www.nbcnews.com/...
Jesse Spector / @jessespector: Literally yesterday. And they respond by publishing PAMELA PAUL defending JK MONTHERFUCKING ROWLING. And yeah, I'm canceling my @TheAthletic subscription over this. Zero more dollars from me. Bye. https://www.nbcnews.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Liana Kerzner / @redlianak: Even I think the @nytimes coverage is insensitive and over the line, and I'm the “transphobe” of the week! https://www.nbcnews.com/...
Noah Berlatsky / @nberlat: the NYT taking a brave stand for free speech by (checks notes) using its power as an employer to silence criticism from staffers. https://www.thedailybeast.com/ ...
Kate Seamons / Newser: NYT Chides Journalists Who Faulted Paper's Trans Coverage
Madeline Leung Coleman / @madelesque: If you'd like to see the actual letter that so many contributors to NYT sent — and not the bogeyman Jonathan Chait seems to think he's responding to — you can read it here. And sign if you feel moved. https://nytletter.com/
Jonathan Chait / @jonathanchait: I understand why activists think critical reporting about youth gender medicine fuels a right-wing backlash. But their view is actually backward. The best way to defuse a backlash is accountability to ensure abuses don't occur. https://nymag.com/...
Jonathan Chait / @jonathanchait: The key premise of the NYT letter is that coverage resources are misplaced because nothing important has changed in youth gender treatment. And that is demonstrably untrue. https://nymag.com/...
Russell Cohn / @cohnrussell: Feel like something the @NYTimesGuild should comment on https://twitter.com/...
Megan Farokhmanesh / @megan_nicolett: the incredible number of writers I deeply admire and respect who've signed, vs those using it as part of a bad faith argument about how it's ~an attack on free press~ says everything https://twitter.com/...
Luke / @lukeoneil47: I am not unsympathetic to this problem obviously but there has to be a line somewhere for a lot of people. https://twitter.com/...
James Palmer / @beijingpalmer: also bear in mind that many journalists have a hard time speaking their mind on this because the NYT makes up such a massive proportion of high-level jobs. It's possible for me because I'm a China nerd who has no interest in working for them and a range of career choices.
James Palmer / @beijingpalmer: this is just going to be endlessly doubling-down on the self-satisfaction of believing that the Times, rather than the trans people it's helping fuel attacks on, is the victim here. https://twitter.com/...
Luke / @lukeoneil47: You are performing advocacy one way or the other whether you are aware of it or not. The difference now is that more of the audience is onto the con and can yell at you about it on Twitter every day. https://www.welcometohellworld.com/ ... https://twitter.com/...
James Palmer / @beijingpalmer: the most effective way to affect change here is going to be for people in NY society to call out NYT management on this in the settings that actually matter to them; private events among the rich and powerful. Be polite, but be clear and firm; they need to feel opprobrium.
Will Stancil / @whstancil: Pretty clear that, in practice, Times leadership believes deeply in their own neutrality as a starting assumption, and thus anyone who criticizes them becomes an activist with an agenda. A perfect little epistemic loop for ignoring criticism. https://twitter.com/...
Will Stancil / @whstancil: The idea that biases could be embedded in their worldview, social contacts, the demographic makeup of their organization - and thus would only be identifiable by outsiders - never seems to occur to Times leadership. Or maybe they think they've evolved beyond such plebian matters.
Hamilton Nolan / @hamiltonnolan: This and the other NYT responses seem to be a total evasion of the question: What justifies the bizarre volume of coverage that one particular framing of this issue gets? I've never heard a remotely convincing explanation that's not incriminating. https://twitter.com/...
Will Stancil / @whstancil: The position of NY Times, always and forever, is that the NY Times exists outside and above society, is not subject to the petty biases that everyone else has, and therefore cannot ever be questioned or critiqued by anyone but certain chosen favorites within the Times. https://twitter.com/...
@samthielman: really remarkable how much they're willing to say that doesn't even touch the substance of the letter and its carefully itemized objections. just upset about being disrespected, as always. https://twitter.com/...
@byjudedoyle: So, basically, if you speak up, you're out. Seems like a solid commitment to examining all sides of the issue! https://twitter.com/...
@woahitsjuanito: 1. This is a massive slap in the face to every writer who contributed to the NYTLetter. 2. The GLAAD letter being conflated with the NYTLetter and used to diminish both at once isn't just insulting, it's actively disingenuous, especially for people claiming they care about truth. https://twitter.com/...
Sydney Bauer / @femme_thoughts: It's a hell of a strategy for the Times to just ignore the letter that came from its own contributors that was sourced and reported and conflate it with an additional letter from GLAAD and other groups. https://twitter.com/...
@samthielman: The GLAAD letter and the Freelance Solidarity Project letter are two entirely different letters. If I'm being accused of lazy misrepresentation I guess one thing I would try not to do in responding to the accusation is lazily misrepresent it https://twitter.com/...
Luke / @lukeoneil47: When Journalist-ists talk like this I feel like I'm dealing with a method actor who refuses to break character in between takes. Oh you're an 1800s farmer in real life? Right here in front of me? That's wild. https://twitter.com/...
Tom Ley / @toley88: imo the archness of this response betrays how ideologically motivated the coverage in question has been. https://twitter.com/...
Richard M. Nixon / @dick_nixon: They learned nothing from Jayson Blair and Judith Miller, both of whom were defended from the top with similar bloodlust. There are thoughtful people at the Times but they know to keep their heads down, even when they are being tarred with someone else's brush. https://twitter.com/...
Carlos Maza / @gaywonk: Cancel your subscription. Don't support a paper that's actively siding with bigotry. It's not worth it. https://twitter.com/...
Katelyn Burns / @transscribe: The contributor's letter was not affiliated with GLAAD. This is a purposeful falsehood. https://twitter.com/...
Felicia Sonmez / @feliciasonmez: Kahn is giving Fred Ryan a run for his money when it comes to treating the journalists at his paper with utter contempt. https://twitter.com/...
Ben Collins / @oneunderscore__: @maxwelltani They're taking sides with this. They're playing dumb by pretending they're not, which is in itself lying to their staff and readers, but they are absolutely taking sides here.
Dell Cameron / @dellcam: In the history of activism, the strongly-worded letter has rarely accomplished anything. It's just an obligatory step used to demonstrate publicly that power can't be reasoned with. If you aren't prepared to escalate beyond it, you aren't really in the fight.
@elivalley: Love an ethics policy that “prohibits our journalists from aligning themselves with advocacy groups” https://twitter.com/... https://twitter.com/...
Karl Bode / @karlbode: it's completely wild that people in the TRUTH AND ACCURATE INFORMATION business are oblivious to both their role in amplifying a bigoted right wing moral panic, AND honestly believe that journalism is best served by silencing their own employees https://twitter.com/...
Dell Cameron / @dellcam: Power's predestined role is to downplay & disregard legitimate concern and exercise force to silence its critics & this is where movements that require greater coordination & participation often Peter out. Action is substantially harder to accomplish than words. https://twitter.com/...
Louis Peitzman / @louispeitzman: It's helpful to their cause to conflate both letters as one letter from an advocacy group rather than acknowledging that the letter they're actually talking about here was written and signed by current and former NYT contributors. https://twitter.com/...
Thomas Zimmer / @tzimmer_history@mastodon.social: As the reactionary assault on one of the country's most vulnerable, most marginalized groups is escalating, anti-"woke" crusaders are focused on the real threat - elite “free speech”: “Famous billionaires need our protection! …
Parker Molloy / @parkermolloy@masto.ai: Remember when NYT got rid of the Public Editor, a position that existed to respond to feedback about the paper's coverage and whatnot? And replaced it with, “Hey, readers can just use social media!” …
Patrick Reilly / New York Post: New York Times says it ‘will not tolerate’ staffers who publicly accused paper of ‘anti-trans bias’
Christie D'Zurilla / Los Angeles Times: Celebrities are standing with GLAAD in protest of New York Times' trans coverage
RELATED:
Issac J. Bailey / Nieman Reports:
The New York Times' response to criticism of its trans coverage portrayed serious journalists as radical activists, a route too many outlets take if challenged — More than 1,000 Times contributors have sent an open letter asking for the paper of record to examine its biases in reporting on trans issues.
Discussion:
@niemanreports, @bgrueskin, @amandabecker, @hillarykwiatek, Fox News, Media Matters for America, @stevesilberman, @melissagira, LGBTQ Nation, New York Daily News, New York Magazine, The Hill, The Pitt News, Los Angeles Blade, Advocate, Pirate Wires, Blogging Through the Breakdown, Boing Boing, @froomkin@journa.host, Poynter and New York Post
Discussion:
@niemanreports: More than 1,000 Times contributors have sent an open letter asking for the paper of record to examine its biases in reporting on trans issues. The paper's response is part of the problem (by @ijbailey) https://niemanreports.org/...
Bill Grueskin / @bgrueskin: “The Times could have invited in some of its critics, to listen, learn, and have a substantive back-and-forth about an issue that is vexing many Americans. Instead, it took the route too many high-profile journalists take when challenged.” Via @ijbailey https://niemanreports.org/...
Amanda Becker / @amandabecker: The NYT had a chance to earnestly grapple with a serious critique of its trans coverage by a serious group of professionals, including journalists who contributed to the paper. Instead, it decided to demean them as activists. https://niemanreports.org/...
@hillarykwiatek: The comparison to crime coverage and Hillary Clinton's emails (remember the incredibly irresponsible Clinton Cash coverage?) in this piece is really spot on. https://niemanreports.org/...
Brian Flood / Fox News: New York Times warns staffers to stop attacking each other in memo defending coverage of transgender issues
Vesper Henry / Media Matters for America: The New York Times rejects calls for accountability after letters suggest anti-trans bias at the paper of record
Steve Silberman / @stevesilberman: Superb, informed reply to @nytimes' grotesque response to criticism of its coverage of #trans issues. https://niemanreports.org/...
Melissa Gira Grant / @melissagira: “He could have saved a few words and just officially slurred them as ‘woke,’ because that's the way it comes across.” https://niemanreports.org/...
John Russell / LGBTQ Nation: Amy Schneider blasts New York Times' anti-transgender coverage as the paper defends JK Rowling
Muri Assunção / New York Daily News: NYT top editor tells staff paper ‘will not tolerate’ journalists protesting its coverage of trans issues
Dominick Mastrangelo / The Hill: NYT editors: Paper ‘will not tolerate’ its journalists protesting coverage of transgender people
Brandon Gorrell / Pirate Wires: The New York Times Response To The GLAAD Trans Letter
Jacob Weindling / Blogging Through the Breakdown: The New York Times Political Section Cares More about its Brand than Journalism
Jason Weisberger / Boing Boing: The New York Times called out for editorial bias about transgender, non-binary, and gender non-conforming people by its own writers
Sheila Dang / Reuters:
Source: Microsoft is demoing the Bing chatbot to ad agencies and is testing inserting paid search ads and industry-specific ad formats into the responses — Microsoft (MSFT.O) has started discussing with ad agencies how it plans to make money from its revamped Bing search engine powered …
Discussion:
Buck Williams / Global Community Weekly: Bing Chatbot ‘Off The Rails’: Tells NYT It Would ‘Engineer A Deadly Virus, Steal Nuclear Codes’
Tristan Bove / Fortune: Microsoft is sticking to its A.I. goals despite user reports of ‘unhinged’ Bing AI in its first week
@davidlee: An Onion-esque headline to the “ChatGPT will disrupt Google!” crowd. Exclusive: Microsoft's Bing plans AI ads in early pitch to advertisers https://www.reuters.com/...
Carl Quintanilla / @carlquintanilla: “.. For example, when a user asks the new AI-powered #Bing, ‘what are the best hotels in Mexico?’, hotel ads could pop up, according to the ad executive.” @reuters $MSFT https://www.reuters.com/...
Chris Stokel-Walker / The Information: My Week of Being Gaslit and Lied to by the New Bing
Laurie Sullivan / MediaPost: Microsoft Shares Bing Chat Tech, What Advertisers Can Expect
Claire Ruth McNellan / Realities & Trivialities: Friday news — The exam I mentioned last week is delayed due to bureaucratic hurdles so I've …
Alex Kantrowitz / @kantrowitz: Nothing like a bot telling you it wants to break up your marriage and then inserting a paid link to a divorce lawyer https://www.reuters.com/...
Aisha Malik / TechCrunch: Microsoft says Bing can be provoked to respond outside of its ‘designed tone’
Will Douglas Heaven / MIT Technology Review: The ChatGPT-fueled battle for search is bigger than Microsoft or Google
Jeffrey A. Trachtenberg / Wall Street Journal:
Barnes & Noble launches a $40/year membership offering 10% discounts, free shipping, and more, like the UK's Waterstones', which Elliott Management also owns — Book retailer also launches free membership program in effort to learn more about its customers
Discussion:
David Lazarus / KTLA: Barnes & Noble wants to be the next Amazon Prime
Tyler Aquilina / Variety:
Fall 2022 global survey: 72% of streaming customers reported becoming frustrated with finding something to watch and 25%+ took 10+ minutes to choose something — Can't decide what to watch on Netflix? Well, it's not going to get any easier. — The streamer has officially discontinued its …
Ryan Glasspiegel / New York Post:
Memo: Sports Illustrated laid off 17 people on February 15, including Executive Editor Adam Duerson; co-EIC Ryan Hunt is retiring in March 2023 after 25 years — Layoffs hit Sports Illustrated on Wednesday as the media business continues to have a rough winter with job losses.
Natalie Hanson / Courthouse News Service:
A Nebraska court rules that a state agency violated state law by requiring independent news organization Flatwater Free Press to pay $44K for public records — The estimate for records requested by Flatwater Free Press jumped from $2,000 to over $44,000 between April and June 2022.
Discussion:
@freedomofpress: A judge rightly blocked a ridiculous attempt by the @NebraskaDEE to charge @flatwaterfreep $44,000 for public records. But the Department still managed to harass the newspaper and stall its reporting, which may have been its goal all along. https://www.courthousenews.com/ ...
John E. Bredehoft / @jebredcal: This appears to go well beyond journalists, and seems to apply to other FOIA and similar requests. “He said once documents have been searched for and identified, any additional layer of review is up to the government — but not part of the total fee.” https://twitter.com/...
Isobel Koshiw / The Guardian:
Russia increases its propaganda efforts in occupied Ukraine with a free package of satellite channels, including 10 TV channels produced for the local residents — Free satellite package is part of attempts to cut off occupied population from rest of Ukraine, say analysts
Discussion:
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace: Carnegie Connects: Inside Biden's Ukraine Strategy With Ambassador Victoria Nuland
@glasnostgone: Moscow's pumping occupied #Ukraine full of propaganda, thereby creating an information “ghetto”. It's cutting off 🇺🇦 TV channels & The All-Russian People's Front (not related to The People's Front of Judea), is installing free of charge, 20 🇷🇺 TV channels https://www.theguardian.com/ ...
Angela Fu / Poynter:
A look at Hearst's decision to hire a dedicated therapist for staff in California and Texas, as part of its effort to better support employees' mental health — Stressed, burnt out and sick of therapists who didn't understand them, San Francisco Chronicle journalists asked for help — and got it.
Discussion:
@oliviamesser: @erinallday I am so so touched. And I did actually quit in early Feb and wrote my Twitter thread that got me the assignment from the incredible @vmochama
Erin Allday / @erinallday: @OliviaMesser It started with you, @OliviaMesser. Your incredibly brave piece on pandemic reporters was the article I sent to my editors, that I referenced in the Poynter piece (for some reason I recalled it coming out in January). Speaking up matters! https://studyhall.xyz/...
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: I've talked about how burned out I became reporting on the pandemic, but I've been more private about the serious mental health impact. Basically, my mental health got about as bad as it can get.
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: Her email, that article and the many sources for it — myself included — led to discussions within the Chronicle about the trauma reporters were experiencing from doing their jobs.
Olivia Messer / @oliviamesser: The fucking bravery from @erinallday in this story. It's remarkable, and it clearly worked. This is exactly what we need in more newsrooms. https://twitter.com/...
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: I began seeing a therapist again and started taking antidepressants for the first time in my life. In 2021, I heard about a reporter working on a story about how reporting on the pandemic was affecting health care reporters.
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: At the time, I worked somewhere that didn't allow journalists to speak on the record about something that wasn't their reporting, so I know I was likely to get turned down if I asked to do an interview. So I spoke to @OliviaMesser on background.
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: What I didn't know — and didn't find out until today — was that a reporter across the country, @erinallday, read that article and sent it to her editors at the @sfchronicle.
Lorenzo Cortes / @hoyatexas: Fascinating, honest, and hopeful thread here about the good work @OliviaMesser did to influence people across the country to get the help they needed in one of our darkest times. https://twitter.com/...
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: And so one of the worst times in my life, an experience I wasn't sure I'd survive, led to the creation of a program to address what I had struggled with and to help my now-coworkers.
Jill Tucker / @jilltucker: THIS! We are so proud of the collaboration to bring in an in-house therapist. Yay @Hearst: “Hearst learned its journalists were struggling. It enlisted a therapist to help.” https://www.poynter.org/...
Shira Stein / @shiramstein: And eventually, that led to the Chronicle hiring an in-house therapist. And hiring me. https://www.poynter.org/...
Erin Allday / @erinallday: @shiramstein I love this thread and I'm so, so grateful you found a way to share your story, and that you can finally own it now. Thank you!!
Trisha Thadani / @trishathadani: “Stressed, burnt out and sick of therapists who didn't understand them, San Francisco Chronicle journalists asked for help — and got it.” More details on our in-house therapist here — Hoping this inspires other newsrooms to follow. Thank you @Poynter! https://www.poynter.org/...
Reuters Institute:
An interview with Ukrainian independent journalist Olga Tokariuk on Ukrainians' attitude toward the media, challenges for local outlets, press freedom, and more — In this episode we discuss the tremendous toll that Russia's full-scale invasion has had on journalists and the news media in the country
Discussion:
@risj_oxford, The Hollywood Reporter, Quartz, @niemanlab, @spj_tweets, European Federation …, Bloomberg, @mitalilive, @rasmus_kleis, @palewire and Breitbart
Discussion:
@risj_oxford: 🇺🇦 Our podcast: One year after Putin's invasion, how is Ukrainian journalism faring? Journalist @olgatokariuk discusses w/@MitaliLive the war's impact on media, journalistic integrity, press freedom and more. Listen and read a full transcript: https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac .uk/ ... Clip below https://twitter.com/...
Jordan Mintzer / The Hollywood Reporter: ‘Superpower’ Review: Sean Penn's Intensive and Very Firsthand Account of the War in Ukraine
Diego Lasarte / Quartz: Biden will renew support for Ukraine in his visit to Poland ahead of the first anniversary of Russia's invasion
@niemanlab: “It was not my choice to be a war reporter ... I never had this dream, as many of my colleagues had, to report from a conflict zone.” https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac .uk/ ...
@spj_tweets: “But the consensus is that, no, we have to report about these things because Ukrainians are also fighting against corruption. Ukrainians are also fighting for a transparent state and transparent government. And the war is no excuse to censor ourselves...” https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac .uk/ ...
European Federation of Journalists: Ukraine: “The preservation of local media is essential to support Ukrainian democracy”
Mitali Mukherjee / @mitalilive: A difficult but important conversation - @olgatokariuk and I talk about what one year of a Russian invasion in Ukraine has meant for journalists. #Ukraine️ @risj_oxford https://twitter.com/...
Rasmus Kleis Nielsen / @rasmus_kleis: “It wasn't a choice to be a war reporter. [It] was imposed on me by this Russian invasion of Ukraine. And many Ukrainian journalists found themselves in a similar situation” @olgatokariuk tells @MitaliLive. “We all tried to contribute in the ways we could” https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac .uk/ ...